THE GRAND JURY EVIDENCE DID NOT SUPPORT THE PEOPLE’S BURGLARY THEORY BUT THE EVIDENTIARY INSUFFICIENCY WAS NOT ARGUED BY DEFENSE COUNSEL; BECAUSE OF COUNSEL’S INEFFECTIVENESS, THE FIRST DEPARTMENT, DESPITE THE GUILTY PLEA AND WAIVER OF APPEAL, REVERSED AND DISMISSED THE INDICTMENT IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE (FIRST DEPT).
The First Department, vacating the conviction and dismissing the indictment, determined the evidence of burglary presented to the grand jury was insufficient. Although the error was not preserved and defendant pled guilty and waived the right to appeal, the First Department reversed in the interest of justice because of counsel’s ineffectiveness: Counsel’s skeletal motion to dismiss could have been strengthened significantly by reference to the grand jury testimony. Counsel ordered the grand jury minutes but did not use them to supplement the “skeletal” motion to dismiss:
The evidence before the grand jury established that defendant was unlawfully in the building, and that the building was a dwelling. However, the evidence fell short of establishing that defendant entered, or remained, in the building intending to commit a crime.
The crime relied on by the People to support the burglary count was the endangering charge. As is relevant here, a person is guilty of endangering the welfare of a child when “[h]e knowingly acts in a manner likely to be injurious to the physical, mental or moral welfare of a child less than 17 years old.” In addition to acts of sexual assault or excessive corporal punishment, examples of conduct which courts have held likely to be injurious to a child include possessing loaded and unloaded firearms and ammunition which were fully accessible to children … ; engaging in domestic violence in front of children against their mother … ; and repeatedly directing vulgar remarks at a toddler over a six week period … .
Here, the evidence before the grand jury was that defendant’s comments made the sisters uncomfortable and afraid, but his statements were not intrinsically threatening, vulgar, or otherwise indicative of an intent to endanger. At no time, either in the elevator or when he got off on their floor did he touch the sisters in any way. This evidence was insufficient to establish the requisite intent to commit the crime of endangering the welfare of a child … .People v Henry, 2026 NY Slip Op 06579, First Dept 11-12-26
Practice Point: Ineffective assistance may justify reversal and dismissal of the indictment in the interest of justice, despite a waiver of appeal and a guilty plea.

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!