THE OFFICER KNEW THE BAG DID NOT BELONG TO THE PERSON FROM WHOM HE RECEIVED “PERMISSION” TO SEARCH IT; THE OFFICER THEREFORE DID NOT HAVE AUTHORITY TO SEARCH THE BAG AND THE DRUGS SHOULD HAVE BEEN SUPPRESSED; CONVICTION VACATED AND INDICTMENT DISMISSED (FIRST DEPT).
The First Department, vacating defendant’s conviction and dismissing the indictment, determined the officer who stopped the vehicle, which was operated by Nunez with defendant as a passenger, did not have the authority to search a bag in which drugs were found. The officer, Decker, had seen the defendant with the bag and knew it did not belong to Nunez. When Decker asked Nunez if he could look in the bag, she said “it’s fine, it’s not mine, take a look:”
… [W]hile Decker had a founded suspicion to inquire as to what was inside the bag, he did not have the authority to search the bag. Decker lacked a “good faith” reason to believe that Nunez, the driver of the Jeep had authority to consent to a search of the bag … . The testimony at the suppression hearing established that Decker knew the bag did not belong to Nunez, and that she never said she had authority over the bag. Decker had already seen defendant in possession of the bag. He observed defendant carry the bag from the house and place it into the Jeep. Nunez repeatedly and explicitly denied that the bag belonged to her, denied knowing the contents of the bag, and stated that the bag had “nothing to do with” her. She also stated that the car belonged to her brother and not to her. Under the facts presented, Decker could not have been said to have had a good faith basis to conclude that Nunez was capable of giving consent to search the bag. Notably, Decker never inquired of defendant of whether the bag was his or whether defendant consented to the search of the bag. People v Jimenez, 2026 NY Slip Op 06577, First Dept 11-12-26
Practice Point: The police knew the bag belonged to the defendant. “Permission” to search the bag from a woman who was with the defendant did not provide the officer with the authority to search it.

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!