THE FOR CAUSE CHALLENGES TO TWO JURORS SHOULD HAVE BEEN GRANTED; NEW TRIAL ORDERED (THIRD DEPT).
The Third Department, reversing the convictions and ordering a new trial, determined the defense for-cause challenges to two jurors should have been granted:
… [P]rospective juror No. 94 stated that he had “a very dim view of substance abuse.” The People did not inquire further into the specifics of that statement, but defense counsel subsequently questioned whether this prospective juror would be impacted if drugs were involved in the case. Although he answered in the negative, counsel continued engaging this individual in questioning by asking if he had already formed an opinion based on hearing the list of the charges against defendant. Prospective juror No. 94 stated that he had, explaining that he questioned “why [defendant] didn’t take the plea.” Counsel explained that there may be many reasons not to accept a guilty plea, including maintaining innocence. In response, prospective juror No. 94 commented that “[12] charges is a lot of charges,” which caused him concern. Defendant lodged a for-cause challenge, maintaining that these statements demonstrated a belief on the part of prospective juror No. 94 that the number of charges defendant was facing implicates his guilt. The People opposed, arguing that these statements did not indicate prejudice. County Court ultimately denied the challenge, stating that this prospective juror had been rehabilitated by the line of inquiry from defense counsel.
Later in jury selection, when asked if he believed the number of charges meant defendant must be guilty of a crime, prospective juror No. 178 stated defendant is “here for a reason.” This prospective juror then answered in the affirmative when County Court probed whether he could follow instructions and disregard the indictment, which the court explained was governed by a different standard than that applicable at trial. Defendant made a vacillating for-cause challenge to prospective juror No. 178, while also simultaneously stating that the court would likely find the prospective juror had been rehabilitated. The People opposed and, when the court denied the challenge, defendant exhausted his peremptory challenges to excuse prospective juror No. 178.
… Prospective juror No. 94’s statements undoubtably signaled that he had already formed an opinion in the matter. Defense counsel’s subsequent questioning did not result in an unequivocal statement of impartiality and County Court made no inquiry of this prospective juror … . As a result, defendant’s challenge should have been granted as to this prospective juror because no rehabilitation occurred. Although a closer call, we find that the court also erred in denying defendant’s for-cause challenge to prospective juror No. 178. This prospective juror was asked whether he could follow the court’s instruction and disregard the indictment. However, by directing its inquiry in this manner, the court “did not specifically address the concern expressed by [prospective juror No. 178] in any meaningful way or otherwise obtain assurances of his impartiality” … . Thus, defendant is entitled to a new trial. People v Mulverhill, 2026 NY Slip Op 06588, Second Dept 11-12-26
Practice Point: Here there was no rehabilitation of two jurors who expressed a bias based on the number of charges. The for cause challenges, therefore, should have been granted. New trial required.

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!