IN THIS CUSTODY PROCEEDING, THE JUDGE DID NOT MAKE SUFFICIENT FINDINGS TO ALLOW APPELLATE REVIEW; MATTER REMITTED (FOURTH DEPT).
The Fourth Department, reversing the custody determination and remitting the matter for specific findings by the judge, determined the judge’s failure to make the required findings rendered an informed appellate ruling impossible:
In its bench decision and the order on appeal, Family Court failed to set forth on the record specific credibility determinations or factual findings regarding matters disputed during the custody hearing. “Effective appellate review, whatever the case but especially in child visitation, custody or neglect proceedings, requires that appropriate factual findings be made by the trial court—the court best able to measure the credibility of the witnesses” … .
Further, it is well established that “alteration of an established custody arrangement will be ordered only upon a showing of a change in circumstances which reflects a real need for change to ensure the best interest[s] of the child[ren]” … . Here, the court failed to satisfy its obligation to make an express finding whether the father, in support of his petition to modify the prior custody order, established the requisite change in circumstances before it analyzed whether an order granting custody to the father was in the children’s best interests. Given the court’s failure to make credibility and other factual findings, we decline to exercise our power ” ‘to independently review the record’ to ascertain whether the requisite change in circumstances existed” … .
Moreover, the court failed to set forth sufficient findings concerning the factors that must be considered in making a best interests determination … , and we conclude that the record is insufficient for us to make an independent determination in that regard … . Matter of Castro v Hawkins, 2026 NY Slip Op 06667, Fourth Dept 11-13-26

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!