The Fourth Department, annulling the determination of the “… New York State Department of Health (DOH), made after a fair hearing, which upheld a determination of the New York State Office of People with Developmental Disabilities (OPWDD) denying [petitioner’s] application for adaptive technology under New York’s Home and Community Based Services (HCBS) Medicaid Waiver program …”. Petitioner has cerebral palsy and has very limited use of his limbs. Petitioner had applied for a robotic arm which can attach to his wheelchair and allow him to pick up objects:
… DOH’s determination that the robotic arm is not medically necessary was affected by an error of law because the agency did not consider the entire definition of medical necessity in affirming OPWDD’s determination. In its decision after the fair hearing, DOH held that the robotic arm was not medically necessary inasmuch as it would not be “preventing, diagnosing or curing” petitioner’s cerebral palsy. … [H]owever, medically necessary care also includes care that “correct[s]” a condition (Social Services Law § 365-a [2]; see 18 NYCRR 513.3 [a]). DOH thus erred in improperly narrowing the definition contained in the applicable statute and regulations … .
DOH’s determination that the robotic arm was not medically necessary was also affected by an error of law to the extent that DOH determined that the arm was not essential and could not perform tasks that an aide also could not perform. The definition of medically necessary does not require that the medical care, services, or supplies be essential (see 18 NYCRR 513.1 [c]), nor do the applicable statute and regulations require that the requested equipment be capable of performing services that cannot be performed by an aide. DOH thus erred to the extent that it applied a definition of medically necessary that conflicts with its own regulations … . Matter of Hamilton v Baer, 2026 NY Slip Op 06618, Fourth Dept 11-13-26
