THE COUNTY SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN HELD LIABLE FOR THE CIVIL RIGHTS VIOLATIONS (18 USC 1983) COMMITTED BY COUNTY EMPLOYEES WHICH LED TO THE DEATH OF AN ARRESTEE; CRITERIA EXPLAINED (FOURTH DEPT).
The Fourth Department, reversing (modifying) the judgment, determined (among many other issues not summarized here) the 42 USC 1983 and state negligence claims against the county should have been dismissed. The lawsuit stemmed from the actions taken by county law enforcement and medical personnel in response to combative behavior by plaintiff’s decedent atter decedent’s arrest. Plaintiff’s decedent died because of the actions taken to subdue him. The Fourth Department explained that the county could not be held liable under 18 USC 1983 for the torts committed by county employees. In addition the state negligence claims against the county were dismissed because they were not alleged in the notice of claim:
… “Congress did not intend municipalities to be held liable unless action pursuant to official municipal policy of some nature caused a constitutional tort” … . As distinguished from the section 1983 claims asserted against the individual defendants, plaintiff’s section 1983 claim against the County required “an official policy or custom of the . . . government itself [that] caused the . . . violat[ion] of [decedent’s] constitutional rights,” which in turn may be “shown by proof that the municipality had a custom or practice that was both widespread and reflected a deliberate indifference to its citizens’ constitutional rights” … . In that way, it must be an act of the municipality itself, not merely an act of its employees, that generates the claim—”constitutional torts committed by [municipal] employees without official sanction or authority do not typically implicate the municipality in the deprivation of constitutional rights, and therefore the employer-employee relationship is in itself insufficient to establish the necessary causation … .
* * * … [T]here was no evidence that any County “policymaker was aware of a subordinate’s unconstitutional actions, and consciously chose to ignore them, effectively ratifying the actions” … , or of the County’s “deliberate indifference to constitutional deprivations caused by subordinates” … . Metcalf v County of Erie, 2026 NY Slip Op 06613, Fourth Dept 11-13-26
Practice Point: Here the county should not have been deemed liable for the civil rights (section 1983) violations committed by county employees. There was no proof the violations were the result of a county policy or deliberate indifference.

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!