THE JUDGE TOLD THE JURY “A PERSON IS GUILTY OF BURGLARY … WHEN THAT PERSON KNOWINGLY ENTERS AND REMAINS UNLAWFULLY IN A BUILDING WITH THE INTENT TO COMMIT A CRIME; THE PHRASE “UNLAWFULLY REMAINS” SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN INCLUDED BECAUSE “UNLAWFUL REMAINING” AND “UNLAWFUL ENTRY” HAVE DIFFERENT ELEMENTS (APPARENTLY THIS WAS AN “UNLAWFUL ENTRY” CASE); NEW TRIAL ORDERED (FIRST DEPT).
The First Department, reversing the conviction and ordering a new trial, determined the burglary jury instruction was incorrect:
Defendant was charged with entering a residential building at 320 West 56th in New York County and taking property from three separate apartments in the building. The court instructed the jury that it could convict defendant of burglary in the second degree if the prosecution proved that defendant “knowingly entered and remained” in the building and the individual apartments he was accused of burglarizing. Specifically, the court stated: “Under our law, a person is guilty of burglary in the second degree when, that person knowingly enters and remains unlawfully in a building with the intent to commit a crime therein, and, when the building is a dwelling.” Defense counsel objected arguing that the correct charge was that defendant “unlawfully entered with the intent to commit a crime therein.”
“In order to be guilty of burglary for unlawful remaining, a defendant must have entered legally but remain for the purpose of committing a crime after authorization to be on the premises terminates. And in order to be guilty of burglary for unlawful entry, a defendant must have had the intent to commit a crime at the time of entry. In either event, contemporaneous intent is required” … . The court’s erroneous inclusion of “unlawfully remains” in its instructions to the jury requires reversal and remand for a new trial.
The People concede that the court erred in including the “unlawfully remains” in its instructions to the jury. They argue, however, that any error was harmless. Since the jury was presented with a definition of an offense requiring proof of two mutually exclusive circumstances, which made it logically impossible to follow the court’s instructions and still convict, a harmless error analysis is inapplicable … . People v Rivera, 2026 NY Slip Op 06557, First Dept 11-12-26
Practice Point: There are different jury instructions for a burglary involving an “unlawful entry” into a building versus a burglary involving “unlawfully remaining” in a building.

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!