MENTAL HEALTH LEGAL SERVICE (MHLS) HAS ORGANIZATIONAL STANDING TO BRING AN ARTICLE 78 PROCEEDING TO REQUIRE THE BRONX PSYCHIATRIC CENTER TO PROVIDE A COMPLETE COPY OF A PATIENT’S MEDICAL RECORD PRIOR TO AN INVOLUNTARY RETENTION HEARING, AND, ON THE MERITS, MHLS IS ENTITLED TO SUCH RECORDS (FIRST DEPT).
The First Department, in a full-fledged opinion by Justice Renwick, over a two-justice dissenting opinion, determined the Mental Hygiene Legal Service (MHLS) was entitled to a copy of the psychiatric patient’s full medical chart prior to an involuntary-retention hearing under the Mental Hygiene Law. As a preliminary matter, the First Department held MHLS has organizational standing to bring the underlying Article 78 proceeding which was triggered by the Bronx Psychiatric Center’s (BPC’s) refusal to provide the medical record:
In order to retain a patient involuntarily for more than 60 days, the hospital must obtain a court order so directing, although the patient may remain hospitalized while the application for such an order is pending … . The hospital must show “that the patient is mentally ill and in need of continued, supervised care and treatment, and that the patient poses a substantial threat of physical harm to himself and/or others”… . On the other hand, MHLS has a duty “[t]o provide legal services and assistance to patients or residents and their families related to the admission, retention, and care and treatment of such persons” … . MHLS further has a duty “[t]o initiate and take any legal action deemed necessary to safeguard the right of any patient or resident to protection from abuse or mistreatment” … .
This Court has found organizational standing under exceptional circumstances involving organizations that were dedicated to protecting a class of individuals who suffered injuries which certain statutes were intended to guard against, and who could not otherwise act in their own interests. …
We find that MHLS has demonstrated a clear legal right to mandamus relief … . … [W]hen read together, [the] statutory duty and regulatory provisions impose upon BPC a compulsory duty to provide MHLS with a copy of its clients’ complete medical charts before their respective retention hearings under MHL 9.31 and 9.33 are held. Matter of Mental Hygiene Legal Serv. v Daniels, 2017 NY Slip Op 08645, First Dept 12-12-17
MENTAL HYGIENE LAW (MENTAL HEALTH LEGAL SERVICE (MHLS) HAS ORGANIZATIONAL STANDING TO BRING AN ARTICLE 78 PROCEEDING TO REQUIRE THE BRONX PSYCHIATRIC CENTER TO PROVIDE A COMPLETE COPY OF A PATIENT’S MEDICAL RECORD PRIOR TO AN INVOLUNTARY RETENTION HEARING, AND, ON THE MERITS, MHLS IS ENTITLED TO SUCH RECORDS (FIRST DEPT))/CIVIL PROCEDURE (ORGANIZATIONAL STANDING, MENTAL HEALTH LEGAL SERVICE (MHLS) HAS ORGANIZATIONAL STANDING TO BRING AN ARTICLE 78 PROCEEDING TO REQUIRE THE BRONX PSYCHIATRIC CENTER TO PROVIDE A COMPLETE COPY OF A PATIENT’S MEDICAL RECORD PRIOR TO AN INVOLUNTARY RETENTION HEARING, AND, ON THE MERITS, MHLS IS ENTITLED TO SUCH RECORDS (FIRST DEPT))/STANDING (CIVIL PROCEDURE, ORGANIZATIONAL STANDING, MENTAL HEALTH LEGAL SERVICE (MHLS) HAS ORGANIZATIONAL STANDING TO BRING AN ARTICLE 78 PROCEEDING TO REQUIRE THE BRONX PSYCHIATRIC CENTER TO PROVIDE A COMPLETE COPY OF A PATIENT’S MEDICAL RECORD PRIOR TO AN INVOLUNTARY RETENTION HEARING, AND, ON THE MERITS, MHLS IS ENTITLED TO SUCH RECORDS (FIRST DEPT))/ORGANIZATIONAL STANDING (MENTAL HEALTH LEGAL SERVICE (MHLS) HAS ORGANIZATIONAL STANDING TO BRING AN ARTICLE 78 PROCEEDING TO REQUIRE THE BRONX PSYCHIATRIC CENTER TO PROVIDE A COM PLETE COPY OF A PATIENT’S MEDICAL RECORD PRIOR TO AN INVOLUNTARY RETENTION HEARING, AND, ON THE MERITS, MHLS IS ENTITLED TO SUCH RECORDS (FIRST DEPT))/MENTAL HEALTH LEGAL SERVICE (INVOLUNTARY RETENTION, MENTAL HEALTH LEGAL SERVICE (MHLS) HAS ORGANIZATIONAL STANDING TO BRING AN ARTICLE 78 PROCEEDING TO REQUIRE THE BRONX PSYCHIATRIC CENTER TO PROVIDE A COMPLETE COPY OF A PATIENT’S MEDICAL RECORD PRIOR TO AN INVOLUNTARY RETENTION HEARING, AND, ON THE MERITS, MHLS IS ENTITLED TO SUCH RECORDS (FIRST DEPT))/PSYCHIATRIC PATIENTS (INVOLUNTARY RETENTION, MENTAL HEALTH LEGAL SERVICE (MHLS) HAS ORGANIZATIONAL STANDING TO BRING AN ARTICLE 78 PROCEEDING TO REQUIRE THE BRONX PSYCHIATRIC CENTER TO PROVIDE A COMPLETE COPY OF A PATIENT’S MEDICAL RECORD PRIOR TO AN INVOLUNTARY RETENTION HEARING, AND, ON THE MERITS, MHLS IS ENTITLED TO SUCH RECORDS (FIRST DEPT))/INVOLUNTARY RETENTION (PSYCHIATRIC PATIENTS, MENTAL HEALTH LEGAL SERVICE (MHLS) HAS ORGANIZATIONAL STANDING TO BRING AN ARTICLE 78 PROCEEDING TO REQUIRE THE BRONX PSYCHIATRIC CENTER TO PROVIDE A COMPLETE COPY OF A PATIENT’S MEDICAL RECORD PRIOR TO AN INVOLUNTARY RETENTION HEARING, AND, ON THE MERITS, MHLS IS ENTITLED TO SUCH RECORDS (FIRST DEPT))