DEFENDANT ATTEMPTED TO LEAVE THE COURTROOM DURING THE SUPPRESSION HEARING AND WAS REMOVED FROM A PORTION OF THE HEARING; BEFORE REMOVING THE DEFENDANT, THE JUDGE SHOULD HAVE WARNED THE DEFENDANT OF THE CONSEQUENCES OF FURTHER MISBEHAVIOR AND/OR ASCERTAINED WHETHER DEFENDANT WAS WAIVING HIS RIGHT TO BE PRESENT; NEW TRIAL ORDERED (FOURTH DEPT).
The Fourth Department, ordering a new trial and a new suppression hearing, determined the defendant should not have been removed from the courtroom during the suppression hearing without first warning him he could be removed if he continued to misbehave:
A defendant’s right to be present at material stages of trial is not absolute, and that right may be expressly or impliedly waived … , or it may be forfeited when the defendant “engag[es] in courtroom conduct so disruptive that the trial cannot proceed in their presence” … . Before a court may lawfully remove a defendant from the courtroom, however, the “defendant must be warned that their continued disruptive conduct will result in removal from the courtroom, unless such warning is impracticable under the circumstances” … . “It will be the rare case where waiting to provide such warning imperils the safety of those in the courtroom” … .
This is not one of those rare cases where it was “impracticable under the circumstances” to warn defendant that he would be removed if his conduct continued (id.). The record shows that defendant jumped out of his chair during the hearing and attempted to leave the courtroom. There is no indication that he attempted to hurt or verbally accost anyone, and he was immediately subdued by court deputies. We cannot conclude that defendant’s conduct “was violent in nature or that it create[d] an emergency necessitating his immediate removal” … . While defendant’s attempt to flee the courtroom may have reflected a willingness to waive his right to be present for the remainder of the suppression hearing, the court, before ordering his removal from the courtroom, did not ascertain whether he wished to expressly waive his right to be present and return to jail and failed to warn defendant that continued “disorderly and disruptive” conduct would result in his removal (CPL 260.20). That was error … . People v Velazquez, 2026 NY Slip Op 06666, Fourth Dept 11-13-26
Practice Point: Here removal of the defendant from a portion of the suppression hearing because he attempted to leave the courtroom warranted a new trial. The defendant should first have been warned that continued misbehavior would result in removal. Or the defendant should have been asked whether he was waiving his right to be present.

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!