THE LANDLORD’S RENT-NONPAYMENT PROCEEDING ACKNOWLEDGED THE EXISTENCE OF THE TENANCY, REQUIRING THE DISMISSAL OF THE HOLDOVER PROCEEDING (FOURTH DEPT).
The Fourth Department, reversing County Court, determined the landlord’s nonpayment action action the tenant acknowledged the existence of the tenancy requiring dismissal of the holdover proceeding:
“Generally, if a landlord initiates a holdover proceeding and then commences a nonpayment proceeding, the nonpayment case operates as a waiver of the right to proceed with the holdover because it reaffirms the tenancy” … . Not only do “the affirmative acts involved in commencing the nonpayment summary proceeding . . . reaffirm[ the] tenancy, but the existence of the nonpayment petition itself . . . is documentary proof of the existence of [the] tenancy” … .
Here, “[o]nce [petitioner] obtained a final judgment for unpaid rent in the nonpayment proceeding, it was conclusively determined that a valid lease existed between the parties” and, under these circumstances, we conclude that “dismissal of the holdover proceeding [is] proper” … . Inasmuch as the nonpayment proceeding cannot be maintained in the absence of a landlord-tenant relationship, and the nonpayment proceeding was commenced after the issuance of the warrant of eviction in the earlier holdover proceeding, “[petitioner] waived its right to maintain the holdover proceeding” … . Matter of Pine View Circle, LLC v Atherton, 2026 NY Slip Op 06628, Fourth Dept 11-13-26
Practice Point: A rent-nonpayment proceeding acknowledges the existence of the tenancy, thereby requiring dismissal of a pending holdover proceeding.

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!