ALTHOUGH THE CITIZEN’S REPORT DID NOT IDENTIFY THE EXACT POTHOLE WHICH CAUSED PLAINTIFF’S FALL, IT WAS SUFFICIENT TO ALERT THE CITY TO POTHOLES IN THE VICINITY, THEREBY RAISING A QUESTION OF FACT ABOUT WHETHER THE CITY HAD PRIOR WRITTEN NOTICE OF THE POTHOLE IN QUESTION (SECOND DEPT).
The Second Department, reversing Supreme Court in this pothole slip and fall case, determined the city did not prove it did not have written notice of the pothole. Although a notice which had been provided to the city did not alert the city to the specific pothole identified by the plaintiff, it alerted the city to the presence of potholes in the vicinity, raising a question of fact on the notice-issue:
The Administrative Code does not set forth any requirements for the specificity of the notice … . Therefore, a notice is sufficient if it brought the particular condition at issue to the attention of the authorities … . To satisfy a prior written notice statute, the notice relied upon by a plaintiff must not be too remote in time or location … . However, a recent prior written notice that does not provide an exact location, but which nevertheless reasonably identifies the area of the purported defect, may give rise to a question of fact for the jury as to the sufficiency of the notice … .
Here, the City failed to establish, prima facie, that it did not have prior written notice of the subject pothole. The City’s submissions included a citizen report made on May 5, 2016, of a pothole at “SOUTHWEST INTERSECTION OF AVE ‘H’ AND NY AVE,” which was marked “closed” on May 11, 2016, only 13 days before the plaintiff’s fall. Although the photograph attached to the report depicted a separate pothole at another corner of the intersection, the citizen’s report nevertheless reasonably identified the area of the purported defect and was not too remote in time or location to bring the particular condition at issue to the attention of the authorities Hernandez v City of New York, 2026 NY Slip Op 06700, Second Dept 11-12-26
Practice Point: Here a prior citizen’s report about potholes in the vicinity was sufficient to raise a question of fact whether the city had prior written notice of the pothole in question.

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!