THREE INDUSTRIAL CODE PROVISIONS APPLY TO INJURY CAUSED BY A CIRCULAR SAW OPERATED BY SOMEONE OTHER THAN THE PLAINTIFF; THE LABOR LAW 241(6) CAUSES OF ACTION SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN DISMISSED (FIRST DEPT).
The First Department, reversing Supreme Court, determined certain provisions of the Industrial Code applied to a circular saw. Plaintiff was injured by the saw as it was operated by someone else. Industrial Code sections 23-1.12(c) apples to that scenario. Also Industrial Code sections 23-9.2(a) 23-1.5(c)(3) apply to a circular saw which does not have a proper cover for the blade. Therefore the Labor Law 241(6) causes of action should not have bee dismissed:
Plaintiff, who alleges that he was injured when the circular saw being operated by his co-worker cut plaintiff’s finger, correctly argues that his Labor Law § 241 (6) claim based on Industrial Code § 23-1.12(c)(1) is not barred simply because he was not the operator of the saw … . Moreover, plaintiff raised an issue of fact as to whether defendants violated the second clause of that Industrial Code section. That clause, which does not refer to the operator, requires that saws like the one at issue have “a movable self-adjusting guard below the base plate which will completely cover the saw blade to the depth of the teeth when such saw blade is removed from the cut.” Plaintiff’s testimony that he had observed on occasions preceding the accident that the part of the saw that secured the blade would get “stuck,” and that the bottom part of the saw did not provide protection from the saw’s disk is sufficient to raise an issue of fact.
Plaintiff’s testimony further served to create an issue of fact as to the applicability of Industrial Code section 23-1.5(c)(3), which requires that “[a]ll safety devices, safeguards and equipment in use shall be kept sound and operable” … .
Finally, this Court has found that a grinder and miter saw lacking protective guards are the types of power-operated equipment that fall within the purview of Industrial Code § 23-9.2(a) … . That section requires that “[u]pon discovery, any structural defect or unsafe condition in such equipment shall be corrected by necessary repairs or replacement.” Volquez v Wade Hampton Apts., Inc., 2026 NY Slip Op 06548, First Dept 11-5-26
Practice Point: Three Industrial Code provisions apply to injury from a circular saw operated by someone other than the plaintiff.

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!