You are here: / / THE POLICE DID NOT HAVE PROBABLE CAUSE TO SEARCH THE VEHICLE IN WHICH DEFENDANT...
,

THE POLICE DID NOT HAVE PROBABLE CAUSE TO SEARCH THE VEHICLE IN WHICH DEFENDANT WAS A PASSENGER WHEN AN OFFICER ENTERED THE VEHICLE TO RETRIEVE THE REGISTRATION AND SAW A HANDGUN; THE DEFENDANT HAD STANDING TO CONTEST THE SEIZURE BECAUSE OF THE PEOPLE’S RELIANCE ON THE STATUTORY AUTOMOBILE PRESUMPTION; THE HANDGUN SHOULD HAVE BEEN SUPPRESSED (FOURTH DEPT).

The Fourth Department, reversing County Court, determined the handgun seized from the vehicle in which defendant was a passenger should have been suppressed. The police arrived after an accident and defendant was standing outside the car. When an officer asked for the vehicle registration, defendant offered to retrieve it, but a police officer standing near the car said he would retrieve it. The officer then saw a handgun that had been hidden from view by the deployed air bag. The court noted defendant had standing to contest the search and seizure because of the People’s reliance on the statutory automobile presumption:

As an initial matter, there is no dispute that defendant has standing as a passenger of the vehicle to challenge its search by virtue of the People’s reliance on the statutory automobile presumption … . … [U]nder the circumstances of this case, we agree with defendant that the officer who conducted the search lacked probable cause to do so … . In reaching that conclusion, we reject the People’s assertion that, based on the holdings of People v Branigan (67 NY2d 860 [1986]) and People v Philbert (270 AD2d 210 [1st Dept 2000] … ), the officer was entitled to enter the vehicle for the purpose of obtaining the vehicle’s registration certificate. Unlike in Branigan, there were no ” ‘safety reasons’ ” in this case preventing the officer from allowing defendant to retrieve the registration himself … . and, here, defendant did not initially fail to produce the registration when prompted to do so by law enforcement (cf. id. at 861-862). Unlike in Philbert … , the officer here, as he confirmed at the suppression hearing, lacked probable cause to search the vehicle and had no reason to believe that the vehicle contained evidence of a crime. People v Lawrence, 2021 NY Slip Op 01921, Fourth Dept 3-26-21

 

You might also like
FALL FROM FIRST FLOOR TO BASEMENT FLOOR IS COVERED UNDER LABOR LAW 240(1), THE UNGUARDED OPENING VIOLATED A PROVISION OF THE INDUSTRIAL CODE.
STIPULATION WHICH WAS NOT MERGED INTO THE JUDGMENT OF DIVORCE SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN DISMISSED AS UNENFORCEABLE (FOURTH DEPT).
DEFENDANT’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON THE LABOR LAW 240 (1) CAUSE OF ACTION SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN GRANTED, PLAINTIFF FELL FROM A SCAFFOLD AND HAD NOT TIED OFF HIS LANYARD (FOURTH DEPT).
PETITIONERS DID NOT TAKE STEPS TO PRESERVE THE STATUS QUO AND THE POWER PLANT BECAME OPERATIONAL AT THE OUTSET OF THE MOTION PRACTICE SEEKING TO VACATE CERTAIN PERMITS WHICH ALLOWED THE PLANT TO RESUME OPERATIONS, THE APPEAL WAS DEEMED MOOT AND THE PETITION WAS DISMISSED (FOURTH DEPT).
Court’s Equitable Power to Set Aside a Foreclosure Sale as “An Instrument of Injustice” Explained and Applied
Separation Agreement Found Unconscionable
THE PEOPLE DID NOT PROVE THE ALLEGED ACTS OF SEXUAL MISCONDUCT OCCURRED AT LEAST 24 HOURS APART; THEREFORE THE PEOPLE DID NOT PRESENT PROOF SUPPORTING A 20 POINT ASSESSMENT FOR A “CONTINUOUS COURSE OF SEXUAL MISCONDUCT:” LEVEL THREE REDUCED TO LEVEL TWO (FOURTH DEPT).
JUDGE PROHIBITED FROM ADDING PROBATION TO DEFENDANT’S SENTENCE OUTSIDE OF DEFENDANT’S PRESENCE, ONCE DEFENDANT WAS RELEASED FROM JAIL ANY ATTEMPT TO INCREASE HIS SENTENCE PRECLUDED BY DOUBLE JEOPARDY RULE.

Categories

Sign Up for the Mailing List to Be Notified When the Site Is Updated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2026 New York Appellate Digest, Inc.
Site by CurlyHost | Privacy Policy

THE COURT LACKED AUTHORITY TO DEEM A NOTICE OF CLAIM TIMELY FILED MORE THAN... ALTHOUGH THE ARTICLE 78 PROCEEDING WAS PROPERLY TRANSFERRED TO THE APPELLATE...