ALTHOUGH THERE WAS EVIDENCE CLAIMANT MADE A FALSE STATEMENT ABOUT THE LEVEL OF HER INVOLVEMENT IN AN ONLINE BUSINESS WHILE SHE WAS RECEIVING WORKERS’ COMPENSATION BENEFITS, SHE WAS FORTHRIGHT ABOUT HER INVOLVEMENT WHEN QUESTIONED; PERMANENT DISQUALIFICATION FROM FUTURE BENEFITS WAS NOT WARRANTED (THIRD DEPT).
The Third Department, modifying the Workers’ Compensation Board, determined there was support in the record for the finding claimant omitted from her application for benefits that she was selling items online while receiving benefits, but the record did not support a permanent disqualification from future benefits. Claimant omitted the information because she had not turned a profit, but she was forthright about the online business when questioned about it:
“The fact that claimant had not yet realized a profit from [the activities] does not diminish [her] obligation to provide true and accurate information regarding [her] employment activities and such misrepresentations are clearly material to [her] claim” … . The evidence here revealed that claimant failed to accurately disclose her level of activity … . …
We note that claimant was readily forthcoming about her activities when questioned and declined to cash benefits checks after she resumed part-time work with the employer … . Based on all the circumstances presented, we do not find adequate support for the Board’s determination that claimant engaged in “an egregious pattern of conduct,” thus warranting permanent disqualification from future wage replacement benefits … . Matter of Conliffe v Darden Rest., 2020 NY Slip Op 06001, Third Dept 10-22-20