VIOLATION OF A TEMPORARY ORDER OF PROTECTION IS A VALID GROUND FOR ISSUANCE OF A FINAL ORDER OF PROTECTION; EXPIRATION OF AN ORDER OF PROTECTION DOES NOT RENDER AN APPEAL MOOT.
The First Department, over an extensive dissent, determined Family Court properly issued a final order of protection after respondent’s violation of a temporary order of protection. The court noted that the expiration of the order of protection did not render the appeal moot because the order “still imposes significant enduring consequences upon respondent…”. The dissent argued that a final order of protection cannot be issued unless a family offense has been committed:
Here, the Family Court found, on the record after a hearing, that respondent had willfully violated the temporary order of protection with his April 3, 2014 emails containing statements clearly intended to harass petitioner. As a result of this determination, the Family Court conducted a dispositional hearing on respondent’s violation of the temporary order of protection, and thereafter issued a new order of protection. The Family Court adhered to the prescribed procedure and did not exceed its jurisdiction by issuing this final order of protection. * * * … [W]e read Family Court Act § 846-a as prescribing the remedies available to the court when a respondent violates a temporary order of protection, which is what is at issue here. Matter of Lisa T. v King E.T., 2017 NY Slip Op 01487, 1st Dept 2-28-17
FAMILY LAW (VIOLATION OF A TEMPORARY ORDER OF PROTECTION IS A VALID GROUND FOR ISSUANCE OF A FINAL ORDER OF PROTECTION, EXPIRATION OF AN ORDER OF PROTECTION DOES NOT RENDER AN APPEAL MOOT)/ORDER OF PROTECTION (FAMILY LAW, VIOLATION OF A TEMPORARY ORDER OF PROTECTION IS A VALID GROUND FOR ISSUANCE OF A FINAL ORDER OF PROTECTION, EXPIRATION OF AN ORDER OF PROTECTION DOES NOT RENDER AN APPEAL MOOT)/APPEALS (FAMILY LAW, VIOLATION OF A TEMPORARY ORDER OF PROTECTION IS A VALID GROUND FOR ISSUANCE OF A FINAL ORDER OF PROTECTION, EXPIRATION OF AN ORDER OF PROTECTION DOES NOT RENDER AN APPEAL MOOT)