You are here: / / Flawed Appraisals Would Not Allow a Determination of the Highest and Best...
,

Flawed Appraisals Would Not Allow a Determination of the Highest and Best Use of the Taken Land

The Third Department determined the appraisal reports submitted for both side were flawed such that the highest and best use of the taken land could not be determined.  The matter was sent back to the Court of Claims.  The court explained the operative principles:

When private property is appropriated for public use, just compensation must be paid, which requires that the owner be placed in the financial position that he or she would have occupied had the property not been taken … . Upon a partial taking of real property, an owner is not only entitled to the value of the land taken — i.e., direct damages — but also to consequential damages, which consist of the diminution in value of the owner’s remaining land as a result of the taking or the use of the property taken … . Damages must be measured based upon the fair market value of the property as if it were being put to its highest and best use on the date of the appropriation, whether or not the property was being used in such manner at that time … . Matter of State of New York…, 2014 NY Slip Op 05002, 3rd Dept 7-3-14

 

You might also like
THE NEGLIGENCE AND NEGLIGENT SUPERVISION AND HIRING CAUSES OF ACTION AGAINST THE WARREN COUNTY DEFENDANTS IN THIS CHILD VICTIMS ACT CASE ALLEGING ABUSE IN FOSTER CARE SHOULD HAVE BEEN DISMISSED; THE COMPLAINT DID NOT ADEQUATELY ALLEGE THE WARREN COUNTY DEFENDANTS WERE AWARE OF THE DANGER POSED BY PLAINTIFF’S FOSTER FATHER (THIRD DEPT).
HERE THE APPELLATE COURT SEVERED PORTIONS OF THE SEARCH WARRANT AS OVERBROAD; THE VALID PORTIONS AUTHORIZED A SEARCH OF THE PHONE FOR EVIDENCE OF CHILD ABUSE; THE SEARCH OF THE PHONE AS AUTHORIZED BY THE VALID PORTIONS OF THE WARRANT TURNED UP A VIDEO OF A RAPE; THAT VIDEO WAS PROPERLY SEIZED PURSUANT TO THE PLAIN VIEW DOCTRINE (THIRD DEPT).
ALTHOUGH THE STATUTE STATES THAT EMPIRE ZONE REAL PROPERTY TAX CREDITS ARE AVAILABLE WHEN THE TAX PAYER MAKES DIRECT PAYMENTS TO THE TAXING AUTHORITY, PETITIONERS WERE ENTITLED TO THE TAX CREDITS EVEN THOUGH THE PAYMENTS WERE MADE FROM A MORTGAGE TAX ESCROW ACCOUNT (THIRD DEPT).
Out-Of-Possession Landlord Liability Criteria Explained
Equitable Relief Sought for the Purpose of Determining a Money Judgment—Plaintiffs Entitled to Jury Trial
CLAIMANT DID NOT TRY TO HIDE THE DOG-WALKING BUSINESS AND WAS ONLY TANGENTIALLY INVOLVED IN THE OPERATION OF THE BUSINESS; THEREFORE THE EVIDENCE DID NOT SUPPORT THE CONCLUSION SHE HAD MADE A MATERIAL FALSE STATEMENT IN HER CLAIM FOR WORKERS’ COMPENSATION BENEFITS STEMMING FROM HER FORMER EMPLOYMENT AS A BARTENDER (THIRD DEPT).
CLAIMANT-NURSE’S MENTAL HEALTH PROBLEMS WERE NOT COMPENSABLE AS THEY WERE NOT CAUSED BY GREATER THAN NORMAL STRESSORS (THIRD DEPT). ​
PLAINTIFF WAS INJURED BY A FALLING TREE LIMB; THE CITY AND COUNTY, AS PART OWNERS OF THE TREE, CANNOT BE LIABLE BECAUSE THERE WERE NO VISIBLE SIGNS OF DECAY; THE PRIVATE PARTY WHOSE NEIGHBOR WAS INJURED BY THE FALLING LIMB, HOWEVER, MAY BE LIABLE BECAUSE HE WAS AWARE THE LIMB WAS WEAK (THIRD DEPT). ​

Categories

Sign Up for the Mailing List to Be Notified When the Site Is Updated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2025 New York Appellate Digest, Inc.
Site by CurlyHost | Privacy Policy

Adverse Possession Criteria Explained Plaintiffs Could Not Demonstrate the Alleged Malpractice Was Proximate Cause...