Teacher’s Termination for a One-Time Mistake “Shocks One’s Sense of Fairness”

The First Department determined the termination of a teacher’s employment was a punishment which “shocked one’s sense of fairness.”  The teacher, who was well-respected and had an unblemished record, was found to have engaged in sexual conduct with an adult colleague in the school building after hours. The incident was highly publicized.  In finding the punishment too severe, the court wrote:

“[A] result is shocking to one’s sense of fairness if the sanction imposed is so grave in its impact on the individual subjected to it that it is disproportionate to the misconduct, incompetence, failure or turpitude of the individual, or to the harm or risk of harm to the agency or institution, or to the public generally visited or threatened by the derelictions of the individuals. Additional factors would be the prospect of deterrence of the individual or of others in like situations, and therefore a reasonable prospect of recurrence of derelictions by the individual or persons similarly employed. There is also the element that the sanctions reflect the standards of society to be applied to the offense involved” … . * * *

While petitioner’s behavior demonstrated a lapse in judgment, there is no evidence that this incident, was anything but a one-time mistake … . Of critical significance is that, unlike matters involving some form of romantic involvement or other inappropriate conduct with a student, petitioner’s engaging in what appeared to be consensual sexual conduct with an adult colleague is not in and of itself either criminal or otherwise improper.  * * *

Nor is there is any indication in the record that petitioner’s conduct will affect her ability to teach or that she intended to inflict any damage on any student. While it is unfortunate that the incident garnered so much attention and was exploited in the media, that in and of itself does not warrant the penalty of termination … . Matter of Brito v Walcott, 2014 NY Slip Op 01813, 1st Dept 3-20-14