The Destruction of Decedent’s Body in a Trash Compactor Gave Rise to a Cause of Action for Loss of Sepulcher
The Fourth Department determined plaintiff, decedent’s sister, had stated a cause of action for loss of sepulcher. The decedent was crushed to death after falling into a trash compactor provided by the defendants. His body was never recovered. The court noted that adult children have “priority” over a sibling to bring an action for loss of sepulcher, but both have standing to do so. Although decedent’s sister has standing to bring the action, she will have to demonstrate she has “priority” at trial (there was no indication the adult children sought to exercise the right to bring the action):
“It is well established that the common-law right of sepulcher gives the next of kin the absolute right to the immediate possession of a decedent’s body for preservation and burial, and that damages will be awarded against any person who unlawfully interferes with that right or improperly deals with the decedent’s body” … . “To establish a cause of action for interference with the right of sepulcher, plaintiff must establish that: (1) plaintiff is the decedent’s next of kin; (2) plaintiff had a right to possession of the remains; (3) defendant interfered with plaintiff’s right to immediate possession of the decedent’s body; (4) the interference was unauthorized; (5) plaintiff was aware of the interference; and (6) the interference caused plaintiff mental anguish, which is generally presumed” … . Shepherd v Whitestar Development Corp…, 1144, 4th Dept 1-3-14