A FOIL REQUEST FOR DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION (DOE) DOCUMENTS WHICH DISCUSS THE IMPLICATIONS OF A US SUPREME COURT CASE WITH REGARD TO STANDARDS FOR COMPULSORY EDUCATION WAS NOT AN INAPPROPRIATE REQUEST FOR “LEGAL CONCLUSIONS” (SECOND DEPT).
The Second Department, reversing (modifying) Supreme Court, determined the FOIL request for Department of Education (DOE) documents describing the implications of a US Supreme Court decision with regard to the standards for compulsory education should not have been denied as an inappropriate request for “legal conclusions:”
Contrary to the DOE’s contention, there is no categorical exemption for “legal conclusions” (see Public Officers Law § 87[2]). The DOE’s reliance on certain advisory opinions in which the request failed to seek records already in existence is misplaced … . Public Officers Law § 89(3)(a) provides in relevant part that “[n]othing in this article shall be construed to require any entity to prepare any record not possessed or maintained by such entity.” Thus, an agency has no obligation to create a new record or to accommodate a request to compile data in a particular format when the agency does not maintain the records in such a manner … . Here, part 3(b) of the FOIL request sought particular “[r]ecords which describe implications of Wisconsin v. Jonas Yoder, 406 U.S. 205 (1972) with regard to standards for compulsory education” … . Contrary to the DOE’s contention, the request does not seek legal conclusions, nor would it require the DOE to conduct legal analysis of its records. The DOE did not contend that it has no records which facially describe implications of Yoder with regard to the standards for compulsory education. Accordingly, to the extent that such records exist, the DOE may not withhold them on the ground that they involve a legal conclusion. Matter of Jewish Press, Inc. v New York City Dept. of Educ., 2026 NY Slip Op 06715, Second Dept 11-12-26
Practice Point: A FOIL request made to the Department of Education (DOE) for documents which discuss the implications of a US Supreme Court decision with respect to educational standards is not an inappropriate request for “legal conclusions.”

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!