You are here: / / PLAINTIFF, UNDER NEW JERSEY LAW, SUFFICIENTLY PLED A SPECIAL RELATIONSHIP...
, , ,

PLAINTIFF, UNDER NEW JERSEY LAW, SUFFICIENTLY PLED A SPECIAL RELATIONSHIP WITH DEFENDANT BANK GIVING RISE TO A DUTY TO ENFORCE ITS ANTI-FRAUD PROCEDURES; PLAINTIFF WIRED $300,000 TO AN ACCOUNT WHICH HAD BEEN SET UP TO DEFRAUD PLAINTIFF (FIRST DEPT).

The First Department, over a comprehensive dissent, determined defendant JPMorgan Chase Bank owed a duty to plaintiff based upon its anti-fraud polices advertised on the bank’s website. Defendant David Tate opened an account at a New Jersey Chase bank in the name of his business, Alchemy. Tate did not provide any personal identification or any corporate documentation to the bank. Plaintiff, thinking she was investing in Alchemy, wired $300,000 to the Alchemy account which was appropriated by Tate:

Under New Jersey law, a bank and its depositor have an arm’s-length, debtor-creditor relationship … . Banks do not have a duty to protect depositors from the wrongful conduct of third parties with whom the bank has done business .. .

Nonetheless, a bank may have a duty of care “where a special relationship has been established from which a duty can be deemed to flow” … . A special relationship may be formed “by agreement, undertaking or contact” … . As pertinent here, an “undertaking” is “the willing assumption of an obligation by one party with respect to another or a pledge to take or refrain from taking particular action” … .

Crediting plaintiff’s factual allegations, construing the complaint liberally, and according it the benefit of every possible favorable inference …, we find that the complaint adequately pleaded that Chase assumed a duty to abide by the anti-fraud procedures that it publicized.

… [P]laintiff has adequately pleaded the existence of a special relationship with Chase, giving rise to a duty to plaintiff to enforce its anti-fraud procedures … . Plaintiff has likewise stated a claim against Chase in negligence, based on its alleged failure to abide by these safeguards when Tate opened Alchemy’s account with Chase … . Ben-Dor v Alchemy Consultant LLC, 2024 NY Slip Op 03797, Second Dept 7-11-24

Practice Point: In New Jersey, to sue a bank for the wrongful conduct of a third party, here the use of a bank account to defraud plaintiff, the bank must owe plaintiff a special duty. The majority held the anti-fraud policies on the bank’s website may be the basis for such a special duty. There was an extensive and comprehensive dissent.

 

You might also like
THE TIME-OF-THE-ESSENCE DATE WAS PROPERLY SET; THE BUYER WAS NOT ABLE TO CLOSE ON THAT DATE: DEFENDANTS-SELLERS ENTITLED TO KEEP THE DOWNPAYMENT (SECOND DEPT).
DESPITE THE HORRIFIC NATURE OF THE CRIME, DEFENDANT’S SENTENCE WAS REDUCED BECAUSE OF HIS MENTAL ILLNESS AND INTELLECTUAL DISABILITY (FIRST DEPT).
Court Has Inherent Authority to Reinstate Indictment After Dismissal for Legal Insufficiency
DEFENDANT DOCTOR’S FAILURE TO APPEAR FOR THE NO-FAULT EXAMINATION UNDER OATH (EUO) REQUESTED BY THE INSURER JUSTIFIED THE DENIAL OF DEFENDANT’S CLAIMS FOR BENEFITS (FIRST DEPT).
PLAINTIFFS’ CONCLUSORY ALLEGATIONS OF AN AGENCY RELATIONSHIP INSUFFICIENT TO DEMONSTRATE A BASIS FOR LONG-ARM JURISDICTION, MOTION TO DISMISS PROPERLY GRANTED.
A CLAUSE IN AN EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT PURPORTING TO WAIVE THE RIGHT TO BRING A CLASS ACTION SUIT AND SUBMIT COLLECTIVE CLAIMS TO ARBITRATION VIOLATED THE NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS ACT AND IS UNENFORCEABLE 1ST DEPT.
CEREMONIAL MARRIAGE SUFFICIENTLY PROVEN, CHILD ENTITLED TO SUPPORT.
BOARD OF RESIDENTIAL COOPERATIVE CORPORATION UNREASONABLY WITHHELD CONSENT TO TRANSFER SHARES AND PROPRIETARY LEASE TO TWO SONS OF THE DECEASED APARTMENT RESIDENTS.

Categories

Sign Up for the Mailing List to Be Notified When the Site Is Updated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2026 New York Appellate Digest, Inc.
Site by CurlyHost | Privacy Policy

IT WAS REVERSIBLE ERROR TO EMPANEL AN ANONYMOUS JURY; ALTHOUGH THE ERROR WAS... FAMILY COURT HAD THE AUTHORITY TO ORDER VISITATION WITH THE CHILDREN’S...