You are here: / / No Contest Clause Was Not Triggered by Offering Will for Probate or Questioning...

No Contest Clause Was Not Triggered by Offering Will for Probate or Questioning Actions of Named Executor(s)

The Third Department, in a full-fledged opinion by Justice Peters, over a dissent, determined that a no contest clause in a will was not triggered by offering the will for probate and was not triggered by questioning the actions of the named executors.  The beneficiary of a 2006 will, who had been excluded from the 2011 will, sought to probate the 2006 will.  The petitioners then sought probate of the 2011 will when the executors failed to do so. The beneficiary of the 2006 will argued that the no contest clause in the 2011 will had thereby been triggered:

While enforceable, no contest clauses are disfavored and must be strictly construed … . The no contest provision at issue provides for revocation of a beneficiary’s interest if the beneficiary “contest[s] the probate or validity of [the] Will or any provision thereof, or . . . institute[s] . . . any proceeding to . . . prevent any provision [of the Will] from being carried out in accordance with its terms.” Here, petitioners did not contest the validity of the will or any of its provisions by seeking to admit the will to probate … . Rather, given that [the beneficiary of the 2006 will who had been excluded as a beneficiary from the 2011 will] had already offered the 2006 will for probate nearly two months earlier, they reasonably undertook to probate the 2011 will themselves after the nominated executor and successor executor thereunder failed to do so.

To the extent that petitioners sought letters of administration, we cannot conclude that, by including the no contest clause in his will, decedent intended to preclude a beneficiary from challenging or otherwise questioning the conduct of a fiduciary. Matter of Prevratil, 2014 NY Slip Op 05478, 3rd Dept 7-24-14

 

You might also like
PART-TIME AEROBICS INSTRUCTOR WAS AN EMPLOYEE.
Regulations Promulgated by Administrative Bodies Are Quasilegislative Acts—Any Challenge to the Regulations Must Be Brought in an Article 78 Proceeding Alleging the Regulations to Be Arbitrary and Capricious
SPECIAL FUND IS LIABLE FOR DEATH BENEFITS WHERE THE CLAIM WAS TRANSFERED TO THE SPECIAL FUND BEFORE THE FUND WAS CLOSED IN 2014 AND THE CLAIMANT DIED AFTER THE FUND WAS CLOSED (THIRD DEPT).
Denial of For Cause Challenge to Juror Required Reversal
PLAINTIFF WAS STRUCK BY A SHED WHICH WAS BEING TRANSPORTED AS AN OVERSIZED LOAD; AN EMPLOYER WHICH HIRES AN INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR WILL GENERALLY NOT BE VICARIOUSLY LIABLE FOR THE CONTRACTOR’S NEGLIGENCE UNLESS THE CONTRACTOR IS TASKED WITH AN “INHERENTLY DANGEROUS ACTIVITY;” TRANSPORTING AN OVERSIZED LOAD BY TRUCK IS NOT AN “INHERENTLY DANGEROUS ACTIVITY;” THEREFORE THE EMPLOYER WAS NOT VICARIOUSLY LIABLE FOR THE TRUCK DRIVER’S NEGLIGENCE WHICH CAUSED PLAINTIFF’S INJURY (THIRD DEPT).
PLAINTIFF’S DECEDENT FELL DOWN A STAIRWAY LEADING TO THE RESTAURANT BASEMENT WHICH WAS ACCESSED BY AN UNMARKED, UNLOCKED DOOR; ALTHOUGH THE ACCIDENT WAS NOT WITNESSED, DEFENDANT RESTAURANT’S SUMMARY JUDGMENT MOTION SHOULD HAVE BEEN DENIED.
DEFENDANT HAD SERVED HIS ENTIRE SENTENCE BY THE TIME THE ASSAULT SECOND CONVICTION WAS OVERTURNED, THE IMPOSITION OF MORE PRISON TIME UPON HIS SUBSEQUENT PLEA TO THE ASSAULT SECOND CHARGE VIOLATED THE DOUBLE JEOPARDY CLAUSE, DEFENSE COUNSEL WAS INEFFECTIVE FOR NOT REQUESTING TIME SERVED, BECAUSE THE ERROR AFFECTED THE VOLUNTARINESS OF DEFENDANT’S GUILTY PLEA THE WAIVER OF APPEAL DID NOT APPLY (THIRD DEPT).
THE MURDER SECOND DEGREE COUNTS MUST BE DISMISSED AS INCLUSORY CONCURRENT COUNTS OF MURDER FIRST DEGREE (THIRD DEPT).

Categories

Sign Up for the Mailing List to Be Notified When the Site Is Updated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2026 New York Appellate Digest, Inc.
Site by CurlyHost | Privacy Policy

Tutors Are Employees Entitled to Unemployment Insurance Costs Properly Assessed Against Carrier for Instituting Proceedings Without...