You are here: / / Lump Sum Settlement with Third Party Barred Transfer of Employer’s...

Lump Sum Settlement with Third Party Barred Transfer of Employer’s Liability for Future Medical Payments to the Special Fund

The Third Department, in a full-fledged opinion by Justice Stein, determined that a lump sum payment from a third party, to which the employer agreed in return for the worker’s forebearance re: future indemnity payments by the employer, barred the transfer of the employer’s liability for future medical payments to the Special Fund:

Pursuant to Workers’ Compensation Law § 25-a, liability for a claim will be transferred to the Special Fund when an application is made to reopen a closed case after a lapse of seven years from the date of the injury and three years from the date of the last payment of compensation … . The issue here distills to when the last payment of compensation was made in light of the settlement agreement between claimant and the employer. …

Pursuant to Workers’ Compensation Law § 25-a (7), where a case is “disposed of by the payment of a lump sum,” the date of the last payment of compensation is established by calculating the date to which the amount paid in the settlement would have extended had the award of indemnity benefits been made at the maximum compensation rate warranted on the date the lump-sum payment was approved … . Here, the employer entered into an agreement with claimant on December 30, 2008 that permitted claimant to retain the proceeds of the third-party action in exchange for, among other things, his forebearance of future indemnity benefits. In our view, these proceeds constituted a lump-sum payment for purposes of the statute. Contrary to the employer’s contention that the statute only applies where the employer itself makes a lump-sum payment to the claimant, we note that the plain language of the statute indicates that it applies “where the case is disposed of by the payment of a lump sum,” without reference to the source of such payment (Workers’ Compensation Law § 25-a [7]). Thus, because the settlement agreement effectively “disposed” of the employer’s obligation to pay future indemnity benefits in exchange for claimant’s retention of a lump-sum payment from the third-party action, application of the statute is appropriate to bar transfer of liability for future medical benefits to the Special Fund. Matter of Nicpon v Zelasko Constr Inc, 2014 NY Slip Op 04102, 3rd Dept 6-5-14

 

You might also like
IN ORDER FOR THE INJURED RAILROAD WORKER TO BE ELIGIBLE FOR WORKERS’ COMPENSATION LAW BENEFITS, ALL PARTIES WOULD HAVE TO WAIVE FEDERAL JURISDICTION UNDER THE FEDERAL EMPLOYER’S LIABILITY ACT (FELA), MATTER SENT BACK (THIRD DEPT). ​
THE TRAFFIC STOP AND CANINE SEARCH WERE JUSTIFIED; THE DISSENT ARGUED THE CANINE SEARCH WAS NOT (THIRD DEPT).
Trial Court’s Decision to Conduct Trial in Defendant’s Absence Without Consideration of the Factors Mandated for Consideration by the Court of Appeals Required Reversal
People Failed to Prove Seizure of Cocaine at Police Station Was Not the Fruit of the Illegal Arrest—Attenuation Not Demonstrated
THE DENIAL OF RELIGIOUS EXEMPTIONS TO THE COVID VACCINE MANDATE WAS NOT ARBITRARY AND CAPRICIOUS (THIRD DEPT). ​
Order Re: an Easement Allowing Plaintiffs Access to a Lake Was Specific Enough to Support Finding the Defendants in Civil Contempt (for Violation of the Order)—Willfulness Is Not an Element of Civil Contempt—Mere Act of Disobedience Is Enough
Audit Procedures, Disclosure of Which Could Impede Investigations, Are Exempt from Disclosure
Restitution Hearing Required/Insufficient Proof to Substantiate the Amount/Conclusory Admission by Defendant Not Enough

Categories

Sign Up for the Mailing List to Be Notified When the Site Is Updated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2026 New York Appellate Digest, Inc.
Site by CurlyHost | Privacy Policy

Claimant-Interpreter Properly Found to Be an Employee, Not an Independent C... No Need to Be Affiliated with an Authorized Rescue Entity or Volunteer Agency...