You are here: / / IN THIS BICYCLE ACCIDENT CASE, WHETHER A ONE-AND-A-QUARTER-INCH GAP IN...

IN THIS BICYCLE ACCIDENT CASE, WHETHER A ONE-AND-A-QUARTER-INCH GAP IN THE ROADWAY WAS “OPEN AND OBVIOUS AND NOT INHERENTLY DANGEROUS” SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN DETERMINED AS A MATTER OF LAW; IT IS A QUESTION FOR THE JURY BASED ON ALL THE CIRCUMSTANCES (THIRD DEPT).

The Third Department, reversing Supreme Court, determined there were questions of fact precluding summary judgment in this bicycle-accident case based upon a 1 1/4 inch gap in the roadway. Supreme Court granted defendant’s summary judgment motion based, in part, on the conclusion that the defect was open and obvious and not inherently dangerous. The Third Department noted that whether a defect is open and obvious is usually a question for a jury:

To the extent Supreme Court dismissed the complaint based upon its conclusion that the gap was open and obvious and not inherently dangerous, we note that “[w]hether a condition is open and obvious does not preclude liability . . . as a matter of law; rather, it is a factor that impacts the foreseeability of an accident and the comparative negligence of the injured party” … . Indeed, “[t]he determination as to whether a condition is open and obvious generally falls within the province of a jury, as it requires consideration of the unique facts presented by the case before it” . “In this regard, the determination of whether an asserted hazard is open and obvious cannot be divorced from the surrounding circumstances, and whether a condition is not inherently dangerous, or constitutes a reasonably safe environment, depends on the totality of the specific facts of each case” … . Here … [plaintiff] indicated that his attention was occupied by a changing traffic light ahead and a moving motor vehicle to the left, and that there were cars parked to his right in…  designated spots. Viewing all of the evidence in the light most favorable to plaintiffs as the nonmovants … , the record does not compel the conclusion that the gap was readily observable with the reasonable use of one’s senses and not inherently dangerous … . Stegman v City of Glens Falls, N.Y., 2026 NY Slip Op 03486, Third Dept 6-4-26

Practice Point: Here in this bicycle accident case, a 1 1/4 inch gap in the roadway could not be deemed “trivial” or “open and obvious and not inherently dangerous” as a matter of law.

 

You might also like
ONCE A STIPULATION OF DISCONTINUANCE WAS FILED SUPREME COURT LACKED ANY SUPERVISORY CONTROL OVER THE PROCEEDING AND THE MOTION PRACTICE SEEKING TO SET ASIDE THE SETTLEMENT SHOULD HAVE BEEN DENIED ON THAT GROUND; A PLENARY ACTION WAS REQUIRED (THIRD DEPT). ​
THE CRIMINAL PROCEDURE LAW SPELLS OUT THE ONLY GROUNDS FOR APPEAL IN A CRIMINAL PROCEEDING; NO APPEAL LIES FROM THE DENIAL OF A MOTION TO CORRECT, AMEND OR SETTLE THE SENTENCING TRANSCRIPT; AND NO APPEAL LIES FROM ADDING A MANDATORY SURCHARGE, WHICH IS NOT PART OF A SENTENCE (THIRD DEPT).
NO INTENT TO PERMANENTLY DEPRIVE OWNER OF HIS PROPERTY, GRAND LARCENY CONVICTION REVERSED.
Odor of Burnt Marijuana Provided Probable Cause to Search Defendant and Vehicle
State Did Not Rebut Statutory Presumption Corrections Officer’s Heart Condition Was Linked to His Work
HERE TWO DISSENTERS ARGUED THE JUDGE DID NOT MAKE THE REQUIRED FINDINGS THAT THE PROSECUTOR’S RACE-NEUTRAL REASONS FOR PEREMPTORY CHALLENGES WERE NON-PRETEXTUAL (THIRD DEPT).
THE BOARD SHOULD NOT HAVE RELIED ON THE OPINION OF AN EXPERT WHO DID NOT FOLLOW THE IMPAIRMENT GUIDELINES BY REVIEWING THE UPDATED X-RAYS OF CLAIMANT’S HIP (THIRD DEPT). ​
RECORDED PHONE CONVERSATION WITH INSURER PROTECTED AS A STATEMENT PREPARED FOR LITIGATION.

Categories

Sign Up for the Mailing List to Be Notified When the Site Is Updated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2026 New York Appellate Digest, Inc.
Site by CurlyHost | Privacy Policy

THE ISSUANCE DATE OF A DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS AND COMMUNITY SUPERVISION (DOCCS)... PETITIONER, THE GUARDIAN OF THE PERSON AND PROPERTY OF AN INCAPACITATED PERSON...