A HOSPITAL HAS A DUTY TO RETAIN AN INTOXICATED PATIENT WHO HAS BEEN ADMITTED INVOLUNTARILY PURSUANT TO THE MENTAL HYGIENE LAW IF THE PATIENT IS INCAPACITATED TO A DEGREE THERE WAS A LIKELIHOOD OF HARM TO THE PATIENT OR OTHERS (FOURTH DEPT).
The Fourth Department, reversing Supreme Court, determined there was a question of fact whether defendant hospital breached its duty to retain the decedent for emergency treatment because decedent was incapacitated by alcohol to a degree there was a likelihood of harm to decedent or others:
A hospital does not owe an intoxicated patient, who went to the hospital voluntarily, a duty to prevent that patient from leaving the hospital against medical advice even when that patient has been admitted to the hospital for medical treatment … . By contrast, however, the decedent here was admitted involuntarily (see Mental Hygiene Law former § 22.09 [e]). Defendant therefore had a duty to retain decedent for emergency treatment if decedent was incapacitated by alcohol or substances to such a degree that there was a likelihood to result in harm to decedent or others, as those terms are defined under Mental Hygiene Law former § 22.09 … .
Assuming, arguendo, that defendant met its burden of demonstrating that it did not breach its duty to ensure that decedent was no longer incapacitated to the degree that there was a likelihood to result in harm to decedent or others, we conclude that plaintiff raised an issue of fact. Plaintiff’s expert opined that, under the circumstances and “especially in such proximity to the events that occurred in the hospital in the hours prior to discharge,” it was a breach of the standard of care to allow decedent to be discharged … . Guadagno v Erie County Med. Ctr. Corp., 2026 NY Slip Op 01698, Fourth Dept 3-20-26
Practice Point: A hospital has a duty to retain an intoxicated patient who has been admitted involuntarily if the patient is incapacitated to a degree there is a likelihood of harm to the patient or others. That duty is not triggered by an intoxicated patient who went to the hospital voluntarily.