You are here: / / CIVIL CONTEMPT AIMS TO COMPENSATE THE OTHER PARTY FOR ANY LOSS ASSOCIATED...
,

CIVIL CONTEMPT AIMS TO COMPENSATE THE OTHER PARTY FOR ANY LOSS ASSOCIATED WITH THE CONTEMPT (FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH A COURT ORDER); CRIMINAL CONTEMPT AIMS TO PUNISH; THEREFORE A $250 A DAY FINE, ALTHOUGH APPROPRIATE FOR CRIMINAL CONTEMPT, WAS NOT APPROPRIATE FOR THE CIVL CONTEMPT AT ISSUE HERE (FOURTH DEPT).

The Fourth Department, reversing Supreme Court, determined fining defendants $250 a day for civil contempt was not appropriate. Civil contempt, unlike criminal contempt, is designed to compensate the other party for any loss, not to punish. The matter was remitted for a determination of any losses to plaintiffs associated with defendants’ contempt. Defendants had ignored a court order requiring that the contested reservation fee (over $700,000) be placed in escrow to prevent defendants from dissipating it:

“Unlike criminal contempt sanctions which are intended to punish, civil contempt fines are intended to compensate victims for their actual losses” … . Plaintiff did not establish an actual loss or injury as a result of the contempt … , and therefore Judiciary Law § 773 authorized the court to impose “a fine . . . not exceeding the amount of the complainant’s costs and expenses, and two hundred and fifty dollars in addition thereto.” Under these circumstances, the fine of $250 per day until the contempt was purged is not authorized by the statute and improperly sought to punish defendants for their continuing contempt, rather than to compensate plaintiff for an amount of damages suffered … . Rpower, LLC, 2024 NY Slip Op 03598, Fourth Dept 7-3-24

Practice Point: Civil contempt aims to address the contempt of the opposing party by compensating for the loss caused by the contempt. Criminal contempt, on the other hand, is designed to punish a party for failing to obey a court order. A fine is therefore appropriate for criminal contempt, but not for civil contempt.

 

You might also like
THE OBVIOUS BIAS OF THE JUDGE IN THIS TERMINATION OF PARENTAL RIGHTS PROCEEDING DEPRIVED MOTHER OF HER RIGHT TO DUE PROCESS OF LAW (FOURTH DEPT). ​
NO ESPINAL EXCEPTIONS WERE PLED SO THE SNOW REMOVAL CONTRACTOR’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT IN THIS SLIP AND FALL CASE WAS PROPERLY GRANTED; QUESTIONS OF FACT WERE RAISED ABOUT WHETHER THE STORM IN PROGRESS RULE APPLIED AND WHETHER THE AREA WAS SLIPPERY BEFORE THE STORM, PRECLUDING SUMMARY JUDGMENT IN FAVOR OF THE OTHER DEFENDANTS (FOURTH DEPT).
Failure to Make Motion for Trial Order of Dismissal Not Ineffective Assistance
Court Was Not Authorized to Deny a 440 Motion Without a Hearing Where People Submitted No Opposition to the Defendant’s Adequate Papers
DEFENDANTS’ EVIDENCE DESIGNED TO RAISE A FEIGNED QUESTION OF FACT, PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT IN LIEU OF A COMPLAINT SHOULD HAVE BEEN GRANTED (FOURTH DEPT).
Larceny Jury Instruction Shifted Burden of Proof to Defendant—Reversal Required In Absence of Preservation of the Error
A COURT’S POWER TO VACATE AN ARBITRATOR’S AWARD IS EXTREMELY LIMITED; AN ARBITRATOR’S INTERPRETATION OF A COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT CANNOT BE REVIEWED UNLESS IT IS “COMPLETELY IRRATIONAL;” HERE THE ARBITRATOR’S AWARD UPHOLDING THE SUSPENSION OF PETITIONER-DENTAL-HYGIENIST FOR HER FAILURE TO OBTAIN A COVID-19 VACCINE WAS CONFIRMED (FOURTH DEPT). ​
POLICE REPORT WAS NOT AUTHENTICATED AND WAS NOT SUBMITTED IN ADMISSIBLE FORM, THEREFORE IT COULD NOT BE CONSIDERED ON THE SUMMARY JUDGMENT MOTION IN THIS CAR-BICYCLE ACCIDENT CASE, PLAINTIFF DID NOT ELIMINATE A QUESTION OF FACT ABOUT WHETHER SHE WAS COMPARATIVELY NEGLIGENT IN NOT SEEING WHAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN SEEN (FOURTH DEPT).

Categories

Sign Up for the Mailing List to Be Notified When the Site Is Updated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2026 New York Appellate Digest, Inc.
Site by CurlyHost | Privacy Policy

ALTHOUGH THE VICTIM, AFTER IDENTIFYING DEFENDANT IN A PHOTO ARRAY, ASKED TO... THE JUDGMENTS ISSUED BY THE NATION COURT FOR A VIOLATION OF A CAYUGA NATION...