THERE WAS EVIDENCE OF TWO PROXIMATE CAUSES OF PLAINTIFF’S SLIP AND FALL: (1) HER KNEE BUCKLED; AND (2) WHEN SHE TRIED TO STOP HER FALL BY GRABBING THE VANITY, THE VANITY MOVED FIVE INCHES AWAY FROM THE WALL (SECOND DEPT).

The Second Department, reversing Supreme Court, determined there was evidence of two proximate causes of the slip and fall: (1) plaintiff/s knee buckled when she stepped out of the shower; and (2) when plaintiff tried to stop her fall by grabbing onto the vanity, the vanity moved five inches and she fell. The building superintendent testified that a properly installed vanity would not move away from the wall:

“There can be more than one proximate cause of an accident, and a defendant moving for summary judgment must show that it is free from fault” … . “‘Generally, it is for the trier of fact to determine the issue of proximate cause'” … .

Here, the defendant failed to establish, prima facie, that the plaintiff losing her balance due to her knee buckling was the sole proximate cause of the accident and that the defendant was free from fault in the happening of the accident … . In support of its motion, the defendant submitted, inter alia, the transcript of the plaintiff’s deposition testimony, at which she testified that, after she lost her balance due to her knee buckling and she grabbed the vanity with one hand, the vanity moved about five inches away from the wall, “and when it moved I lost my balance even more and that’s when I fell.” Moreover, the plaintiff testified that the vanity had been installed around “a couple of weeks” prior to the accident. The defendant also submitted the transcript of the deposition testimony of the superintendent for the apartment building, who testified that a vanity which had been properly installed should not move away from the bathroom wall through “normal use.” Moe-Salley v Highbridge House Ogden, LLC, 2023 NY Slip Op 01187, Second Dept 3-8-23

Practice Point: There can be more than one proximate cause of a slip and fall. Here plaintiff’s knee buckled as she stepped out of the shower. When she tried to stop her fall by grabbing the vanity, the vanity moved and she fell. There was testimony that a properly installed vanity would not move away from the wall.