You are here: / / THE WAIVER OF INDICTMENT WAS JURISDICTIONALLY DEFECTIVE BECAUSE IT DID...

THE WAIVER OF INDICTMENT WAS JURISDICTIONALLY DEFECTIVE BECAUSE IT DID NOT PRECISELY IDENTIFY WHICH OF TWO UNDERLYING OFFENSES IT DESCRIBED AND DID NOT PROTECT AGAINST DOUBLE JEOPARDY (FOURTH DEPT).

The Fourth Department, vacating defendant’s guilty plea and the waiver of indictment, determined the waiver of indictment was jurisdictionally defective because it was not clear which of two charged rapes it referred to and there was no language that the plea would be in full satisfaction of all charges:

… [T]he underlying felony complaint alleged four offenses predicated on defendant’s purported violation of three Penal Law provisions: two separate acts of rape in the first degree that occurred in September and October 2016, respectively (Penal Law § 130.35 [4]), an act of criminal sexual act in the first degree that occurred in November 2016 (§ 130.50 [4]), and acts that constituted endangering the welfare of a child (§ 260.10 [1]). In contrast, the waiver of indictment listed only a single count to be charged in the SCI [superior court information]: a count of rape in the first degree that allegedly occurred sometime between July and November 2016. Inasmuch as the sole charge in the waiver of indictment and SCI could plausibly refer to either of the acts of rape in the first degree alleged in the felony complaint, the waiver of indictment failed to put defendant on notice of the precise crime for which he was waiving prosecution by indictment and was thus jurisdictionally defective. …

In addition to impeding defendant’s ability to prepare a defense … , the defect in the waiver of indictment—i.e., the indeterminancy of the precise rape offense for which defendant was agreeing to waive indictment—implicates double jeopardy concerns because there was no language in the waiver form, SCI, or at the plea colloquy informing defendant that his plea to one count of rape in the first degree would be in full satisfaction of the offenses alleged in the felony complaint. Consequently, defendant could potentially be subjected to a subsequent prosecution for the offenses not identified in the waiver of indictment or charged in the SCI … . People v Meeks, 2021 NY Slip Op 01925, Fourth Dept 3-26-21

 

You might also like
HERE THE VILLAGE SOUGHT TO ANNUL THE CITY’S IMPOSITION OF HIGHER SEWER CHARGES; THE CITY INTERPOSED SEVERAL COUNTERCLAIMS THAT WERE BASED ON THEORIES NOT INCLUDED IN THE CITY’S EARLIER NOTICE OF CLAIM WHICH ALLEGED ONLY BREACH OF CONTRACT; BECAUSE THE COUNTERCLAIMS RAISED THEORIES NOT ENCOMPASSED BY THE CITY’S EARLIER NOTICE OF CLAIM, THEY WERE DISMISSED (FOURTH DEPT).
PEOPLE PROPERLY ALLOWED TO IMPEACH THEIR OWN WITNESS, THE WITNESS’S TESTIMONY AFFIRMATIVELY DAMAGED THE PEOPLE’S CASE AND WAS NOT, AS ARGUED BY THE CONCURRING JUSTICES, MERELY NEUTRAL OR UNHELPFUL.
PEOPLE’S REQUEST FOR AN ADJOURNMENT WHEN TWO DEPUTIES DID NOT SHOW UP FOR A MAPP HEARING SHOULD HAVE BEEN GRANTED 4TH DEPT.
NEGLECT FINDINGS BASED ON MOTHER’S MENTAL ILLNESS AND INADEQUATE SHELTER, EDUCATION, HYGIENE OR CLOTHING NOT SUPPORTED BY THE EVIDENCE; CRITERIA EXPLAINED IN SOME DEPTH (FOURTH DEPT).
THE EVIDENCE OF “PHYSICAL INJURY” WAS LEGALLY INSUFFICIENT; ASSAULT SECOND CONVICTION REVERSED (FOURTH DEPT).
Court Did Not Have Power to Amend Child Support, Maintenance Judgment.
DEFENDANT IN THIS MANSLAUGHTER CASE WAS THE VICTIM OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AND SHOULD HAVE BEEN SENTENCED UNDER THE ALTERNATIVE SENTENCING SCHEME IN THE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SURVIVORS JUSTICE ACT (FOURTH DEPT). ​
THE SENTENCING JUDGE MUST “PRONOUNCE SENTENCE ON EACH COUNT;” MATTER REMITTED FOR RESENTENCING (FOURTH DEPT).

Categories

Sign Up for the Mailing List to Be Notified When the Site Is Updated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2026 New York Appellate Digest, Inc.
Site by CurlyHost | Privacy Policy

ALTHOUGH THE ARTICLE 78 PROCEEDING WAS PROPERLY TRANSFERRED TO THE APPELLATE... DEFENDANT’S CONVICTIONS RELATING TO THE CODEFENDANT’S POSSESSION...