You are here: / / NEW RULE ALLOWING THE NYC CIVILIAN COMPLAINT REVIEW BOARD TO INVESTIGATE...
,

NEW RULE ALLOWING THE NYC CIVILIAN COMPLAINT REVIEW BOARD TO INVESTIGATE SEXUAL MISCONDUCT ALLEGATIONS AGAINST POLICE OFFICERS IS INVALID; PUBLIC VETTING PROCESS WAS NOT FOLLOWED (FIRST DEPT).

The First Department, over a dissent, in a comprehensive decision too detailed to fairly summarize, reversing (modifying) Supreme Court, determined certain Rules of City of New York Civilian Complaint Review Board adopted in 2018 were valid, but the 2018 resolution to begin investigating sexual misconduct allegations against police officers was invalid:

Defendant-respondent The New York City Civilian Complaint Review Board (the CCRB) investigates allegations of police misconduct toward members of the public (NY City Charter § 440[a]). It is empowered to receive, investigate, hear, make findings, and recommend action upon complaints that allege misconduct involving excessive use of force, abuse of authority, discourtesy or use of offensive language … . At issue in this appeal are certain amended rules adopted by the CCRB in 2018 … and a resolution, also adopted in 2018, to begin investigating sexual misconduct, which previously had been referred to the New York City Police Department (NYPD) Internal Affairs Bureau (IAB). * * *

By declaring that the CCRB would assert jurisdiction over an entire category of misconduct that it had historically referred as a matter of policy, the resolution announced a sweeping policy change that materially affected the rights of all alleged victims of sexual misconduct and allegedly offending police officers “equally and without exception,” and thus amounted to the adoption of a new “rule” … . However, because the CCRB undisputedly did not follow the public vetting process required … for adopting a new rule, the sexual misconduct resolution is a nullity … . Matter of Lynch v New York City Civilian Complaint Review Bd., 2020 NY Slip Op 03062, First Dept 5-28-20

 

You might also like
BG, AN ADOLESCENT OFFENDER (AO) WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE “RAISE THE AGE ACT,” ASSAULTED A MAN AND THREW HIM ON THE SUBWAY TRACKS; A BYSTANDER JUMPED DOWN TO HELP THE ASSAULT VICTIM; THE BYSTANDER WAS KILLED BY A SUBWAY TRAIN WHICH STOPPED BEFORE REACHING THE ASSAULT VICTIM; THE JUDGE RULED THE MATTER SHOULD BE TRANSFERRED TO FAMILY COURT; THE PEOPLE SOUGHT A WRIT OF PROHIBITION WHICH WAS DENIED (FIRST DEPT).
Defense Counsel, Not Defendant, Has the Ultimate Authority to Determine Whether Defendant Should Testify Before the Grand Jury
THE TRIAL EVIDENCE DID NOT SUPPORT THE PLAINTIFF’S EXPERT’S TESTIMONY THAT DEFECTS IN THE HANDRAIL OR THE STAIR RISER HEIGHTS CONSTITUTED THE PROXIMATE CAUSE OF PLAINTIFF’S FALL IN THIS STAIRWAY SLIP AND FALL CASE, THE OVER $500,000 PLAINTIFF’S VERDICT WAS VACATED AND A NEW TRIAL ORDERED (FIRST DEPT).
ALTHOUGH DEFENDANTS’ INSURER OBTAINED A DECLARATORY JUDGMENT (BY DEFAULT) THAT IT WAS NOT OBLIGATED TO PAY NO-FAULT BENEFITS TO PLAINTIFF PEDESTRIAN IN THIS TRAFFIC ACCIDENT CASE, THE DECLARATORY JUDGMENT DID NOT PRECLUDE, UNDER EITHER CLAIM OR ISSUE PRECLUSION, PLAINTIFF’S PERSONAL INJURY ACTION AGAINST DEFENDANTS (FIRST DEPT).
Acknowledgment of Debt in Bankruptcy Proceeding Restarted Statute of Limitations 
Being Thrown from the Forks of a Forklift Is a Gravity Related Event Under Labor Law 240 (1)
CONDITION OF PAROLE THAT PETITIONER NEVER ENTER QUEENS COUNTY WITH NO PROVISION FOR OBTAINING PERMISSION TO TRAVEL THERE VIOLATED PETITIONER’S RIGHT TO TRAVEL AND RIGHT TO ASSOCIATE (FIRST DEPT).
Termination of Teacher for Failure to Control Special-Education Class to Which He Was Assigned After an Unblemished 18-Year Career Shocked the Court’s Sense of Fairness

Categories

Sign Up for the Mailing List to Be Notified When the Site Is Updated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2025 New York Appellate Digest, Inc.
Site by CurlyHost | Privacy Policy

FORECLOSURE SALE EXTINGUISHES THE RIGHT TO REDEEM (SECOND DEPT). THERE WAS A QUESTION OF FACT WHETHER WATER ON THE FLOOR RESULTED FROM A RECURRING...