The Second Department, reversing Supreme Court, determined plaintiffs’ protracted delay in substituting father for the deceased infant in this medical malpractice action did not require dismissal of the complaint because the defendants were in possession of all the relevant medical records and therefore were not prejudiced by the delay. The court also noted that motion to amend the complaint to assert wrongful death should have been granted under the relation-back doctrine:
CPLR 1021 requires a motion for substitution to be made within a reasonable time … , and the determination of whether the timing is reasonable requires consideration of several factors, including the diligence of the party seeking substitution, the prejudice to the other parties, and whether the party to be substituted has shown that the action or the defense has potential merit … . Here, the plaintiffs moved, inter alia, for leave to substitute Jean Petion, who is the father of the plaintiff Jeremiah Prince Petion (hereinafter the deceased infant) and administrator of the deceased infant’s estate (hereinafter the administrator), in place of the deceased infant as a party plaintiff and to amend the caption accordingly. Although the plaintiffs admit that the delay in seeking the substitution of the administrator was protracted … , the plaintiffs showed that there was no prejudice to the defendants because the defendants were on notice of the claims against them as early as February 2, 2009, when the plaintiffs filed a notice of claim against the defendant New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation, and the defendants possessed all of the relevant medical records … . In opposition, the defendants asserted only conclusory allegations of prejudice based solely on the passage of time … . The plaintiffs also demonstrated that they have potentially meritorious causes of action through their expert’s affidavit of merit, the pleadings, and the testimony of Marie Petion at the General Municipal Law § 50-h hearing … . Petion v New York City Health & Hosps. Corp., 2019 NY Slip Op 06107, Second Dept 8-7-19