RECORD WAS INSUFFICIENT TO DETERMINE THE LEVEL OF PREJUDICE CAUSED BY PLAINTIFF’S FAILURE TO PRESERVE THE PHONE WHICH ALLEGEDLY CAPTURED IMAGES OF THE INCIDENT AT THE HEART OF THE LAWSUIT, DISMISSAL OF THE COMPLAINT REVERSED AND MATTER REMITTED FOR FURTHER DISCOVERY (THIRD DEPT).
The Third Department, in a full-fledged opinion by Justice Garry, determined that the record was not sufficient to conclude whether dismissal of the complaint was a proper sanction for spoliation of evidence. Plaintiff alleged defendant negligently or intentionally struck defendant with an all-terrain vehicle (ATV). Defendant asked plaintiff to preserve a phone which allegedly contained images of the incident. Plaintiff did not preserve the phone but provided one image and one video which were alleged to have been on the phone. Supreme Court dismissed the complaint as a sanction for spoliation. The Third Department noted there was evidence that all the metadata on the phone had been preserved and remitted the matter for discovery and, if necessary, an appropriate sanction:
… [T]he factors to be considered in determining the appropriate sanctions for such failures are “the extent that the spoliation of evidence may prejudice a party and whether a dismissal will be necessary as a matter of elementary fairness” … . …
… [W]e remit to Supreme Court with direction for plaintiff to promptly obtain and provide to defendant all photos, videos and metadata pertinent to the incident that have been preserved in any source, or to provide defendant with full access to any such stored photos, videos and metadata. The retrieval and examination of this information — or the continued failure to do so — will permit Supreme Court to reexamine, upon a full record, whether pertinent electronic information has been lost as a result of plaintiff’s failure to preserve the phone, to what extent defendant has been prejudiced by that loss and, thus, whether dismissal, an adverse inference charge or some other sanction may be appropriate … . LaBuda v LaBuda, 2019 NY Slip Op 05372, Third Dept 7-3-19