HOTEL NOT ENTITLED TO CREDIT FOR SALES TAX FOR CONTINENTAL BREAKFASTS PURCHASED FROM A THIRD PARTY, CONTINENTAL BREAKFASTS WERE INCLUDED IN THE ROOM RENTAL AND WERE NOT PURCHASED FOR RESALE (THIRD DEPT).
The Third Department determined the hotel (Washington Square) which included continental breakfast in its room rental was not entitled to a credit for sales tax paid by the hotel for the purchase of the continental breakfasts (from Cafe C-III):
Generally, sales tax must be paid upon the sale of all tangible personal property … . However, “[c]ertain purchases which are made for resale are not subject to sales tax” … . As such, a reseller may claim a tax credit for sales tax it paid upon purchases of personal property that will be resold … . “Where the question is whether certain purchases are entitled to the resale exemption, the purchaser must show, to avoid imposition of the sales tax on the entire transaction, that each of the items was purchased for one and only one purpose: resale” … . * * *
We conclude that Washington Square failed to satisfy its burden of establishing its entitlement to the benefit of the resale tax exemption … . According to the hearing testimony of Washington Square’s chief executive officer, Washington Square purchased continental breakfasts from Cafe C-III and such breakfasts were included in the hotel rental fee paid by the guests. Washington Square paid Cafe C-III regardless of whether a guest consumed the continental breakfast. More critically, the chief executive officer also stated that hotel guests would not be separately billed for the continental breakfasts … . …
Nor do we find any merit in Washington Square’s equitable estoppel argument. “[T]he doctrine of estoppel does not apply in tax cases unless unusual circumstances support a finding of manifest injustice” … . The fact that Washington Square, in a prior audit, was not imposed an additional tax assessment where it sought the same tax credit as in this case does not rise to the level of a manifest injustice especially in light of the auditor’s testimony that each audit stands on its own and does not bind a future audit … . Washington Square’s reliance on an audit of Cafe C-III is likewise unavailing. Matter of Washington Sq. Hotel LLC v Tax Appeals Trib. of The State of New York, 2017 NY Slip Op 08422, Third Dept 11-30-17
TAX LAW (SALES TAX, HOTEL NOT ENTITLED TO CREDIT FOR SALES TAX FOR CONTINENTAL BREAKFASTS PURCHASED FROM A THIRD PARTY, CONTINENTAL BREAKFASTS WERE INCLUDED IN THE ROOM RENTAL AND WERE NOT PURCHASED FOR RESALE (THIRD DEPT))/SALES TAX (SALES TAX, HOTEL NOT ENTITLED TO CREDIT FOR SALES TAX FOR CONTINENTAL BREAKFASTS PURCHASED FROM A THIRD PARTY, CONTINENTAL BREAKFASTS WERE INCLUDED IN THE ROOM RENTAL AND WERE NOT PURCHASED FOR RESALE (THIRD DEPT))