You are here: / / Police Officer’s Observations Filtered Through His Experience Justified...
,

Police Officer’s Observations Filtered Through His Experience Justified Stop and Frisk

The Second Department, over a dissent, determined that the street stop of the defendant was justified by reasonable suspicion. Here the officer said he made eye contact with the defendant, saw an outline of a rectangular object under defendant’s clothes and the defendant’s movements were consistent with adjusting a weapon under the waistband. The majority held that was enough, because the officer could rely on his experience to interpret the defendant’s movements. The dissent argued that making eye contact, seeing the outline of a rectangular object, and the defendant’s adjusting his waistband was not enough to justify the stop:

“In determining whether an individual’s actions rise to the level of reasonable suspicion, police officers are permitted to interpret the behavior in light of their training and experience” … . Here, in contrast to the opinion of our dissenting colleague, the factual circumstances described by Mourad, coupled with the officer’s experience and training, were sufficient to permit him to request information from the defendant … . The decision to make inquiry of the defendant did not stem from mere “whim or caprice,” but was objectively based upon observation of the defendant’s actions as filtered through the officer’s experience … . Officer Mourad specifically testified that he believed the shape of the concealed object which he observed under the defendant’s clothing was the outline of a gun … . Mourad explained that the defendant moved in a way that he recognized, from experience, as typical of attempts to adjust a firearm kept in a waistband …, and further testified that the defendant began to increase his pace after the officers exited their vehicle and announced their presence … . Accordingly, there was reasonable suspicion to stop and frisk the defendant … . People v Fletcher, 2015 NY Slip Op 06366, 2nd Dept 7-29-15

 

You might also like
BANK DID NOT SUBMIT SUFFICIENT PROOF OF A LOST NOTE AND COMPLIANCE WITH NOTICE REQUIREMENTS IN THIS FORECLOSURE ACTION; SUMMARY JUDGMENT SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN GRANTED (SECOND DEPT).
Time-Limit for Serving a Complaint Was Never Triggered Because the Summons with Notice Was Filed But Not Yet Served at the Time Defendants Served a Notice of Appearance and Demand for a Complaint
DEFENDANT WAS HOUSED FIVE HOURS AWAY FROM THE COURT AND HIS ATTORNEY, REPEATED REQUESTS TO MOVE DEFENDANT CLOSER WERE GRANTED BUT NOT COMPLIED WITH, DEFENDANT MOVED TO WITHDRAW HIS PLEA AT SENTENCING, GIVEN THE POSSIBILITY DEFENDANT HAD EFFECTIVELY BEEN DEPRIVED OF HIS RIGHT TO COUNSEL, INQUIRY INTO THE VOLUNTARINESS OF OF THE PLEA SHOULD HAVE BEEN CONDUCTED (SECOND DEPT).
THE INSTRUMENT SHOULD HAVE BEEN ADMITTED TO PROBATE AS A LOST WILL (SECOND DEPT).
DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO COMPEL PLAINTIFF TO ALLOW THE EX PARTE INTERVIEW OF THE NONPARTY TREATING PHYSICIAN’S ASSISTANT ABOUT PLAINTIFF’S EXPLANATION OF THE CAUSE OF HER SLIP AND FALL WAS PROPERLY DENIED (SECOND DEPT).
Complaint Stated Cause of Action for Legal Malpractice/Court Rejected Argument that Defect in Service Could Have Been Cured by Successor Counsel as Speculative
Although Defendant Was Not Responsible for the Pedestrian Ramp, There Was a Question of Fact Whether Defendant’s Snow Removal (from the Ramp) Created the Dangerous Condition
ONCE AGAIN, BECAUSE THE RELEVANT BUSINESS RECORDS WERE NOT ATTACHED TO THE AFFIDAVITS, THE STATEMENTS IN THE AFFIDAVITS WERE HEARSAY; PLAINTIFF BANK DID NOT PROVE STANDING TO FORECLOSE OR DEFENDANT’S DEFAULT (SECOND DEPT). ​

Categories

Sign Up for the Mailing List to Be Notified When the Site Is Updated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2026 New York Appellate Digest, Inc.
Site by CurlyHost | Privacy Policy

The Prejudicial Effect of the Result of the Portable Breath Test (PBT) Outweighed... Breach of Contract Action Against School District Untimely—Notice of Claim...