Driver with Right of Way Who Strikes a Vehicle Which Suddenly Enters the Right of Way Is Free from Negligence (No Need to Apply the Emergency Doctrine)/Emergency Doctrine Does Not Automatically Absolve a Driver of Liability

The Fourth Department noted that a driver with the right of way who strikes a vehicle which suddenly enters his or her path is free of negligence absent speeding or some other negligent conduct (no need to apply the emergency doctrine).  The court further noted that the emergency doctrine does not automatically absolve a person of liability.  Here there was a question whether the brakes on the vehicle confronted with the emergency were maintained properly and whether swerving was reasonable:

The existence of an emergency and the reasonableness of a driver’s response thereto generally constitute issues of fact” … . We conclude that there are issues of fact whether the Marriotts’ maintenance of their pickup truck was adequate and thus whether the brake failure was truly unexpected and without any fault on their part. Moreover, it cannot be concluded as a matter of law that swerving to the right in order to avoid rear-ending the garbage truck was a reasonable reaction to the emergency created by the loss of brakes on the pickup truck. Colangelo v Marriott, 2014 NY Slip Op 05746, 4th Dept 8-8-14