Suit by Beneficiaries to Recoup Estate Property, Alleging Breach of Fiduciary Duty by Executor, Allowed to Go Forward
The Third Department determined the beneficiaries of an estate had stated a cause of action to recoup property for an estate (the role of the executor). The complaint alleged misappropriation of decedent’s assets and included a cause of action against the executor (DiMaggio) for breach of fiduciary duty:
Initially, we note that, absent extraordinary circumstances, beneficiaries of an estate generally do not have a right to bring an action seeking to recoup property for the estate since that role belongs to the executor … . However, such extraordinary circumstances may be implicated where the executor is allegedly directly involved in purported egregious conduct and self-dealing that negatively impacts the potential assets of the estate … . When asserting conduct involving fraud or undue influence, the complaint must set forth in detail the circumstances constituting the wrong (see CPLR 3016 [b]…). .
Plaintiffs’ amended complaint sets forth a series of purported acts by defendants occurring during the last two years of decedent’s life when she was allegedly suffering from cancer and depression. Among other things, defendants allegedly induced decedent to give DiMaggio power of attorney by telling decedent that she would retain control over her accounts, but then used the power of attorney to withdraw funds, modify ownership interest, and change beneficiaries on accounts. Plaintiffs contend that defendants convinced decedent to cash about $360,000 in United States savings bonds by informing her it was illegal to continue to hold the bonds and that the government would take all her money. Most of that money was moved into a trust that defendants allegedly falsely informed decedent would benefit her descendants when proceeds of the trust actually went to defendants and their families. Plaintiffs further assert thatDiMaggio, who was substituted for decedent’s daughter as executor when decedent executed a new will in 2007, neglected to make an effort to recover funds inappropriately diverted from the estate. Lewis v DiMaggio…, 516811, 3rd Dept 3-6-14