Jury’s Consulting a Dictionary Justified Mistrial

In upholding the trial court’s grant of a mistrial because the jury consulted a dictionary, the First Department wrote:

…[The court properly determined that the jury’s act of consulting an outside dictionary on a term critical to its decision constitutes misconduct warranting a mistrial, especially since the foreperson indicated that the jury was “confused” about the term “substantial” and the court was unable to give curative instructions … .  However, because the jury’s misconduct related only to the issue of liability, and there is no evidence that it affected the jury’s determination on damages, we reinstate the verdict on damages … .  Olshantesky v New York City Tr Auth, 2013 NY Slip Op 02685, 1st Dept, 4-23-13