THE BUS DRIVER VIOLATED THE VEHICLE AND TRAFFIC LAW AND WAS NEGLIGENT AS A MATTER OF LAW; DEFENSE VERDICT SET ASIDE (THIRD DEPT).
The Second Department, setting aside the defense verdict in this traffic accident case, determined the bus driver was negligent as a matter of law. To avoid a stopped vehicle the driver (Barreto) crossed a double yellow line and lost control of the bus which crashed into a store. The plaintiffs were bus passengers:
This Court has held that “a driver who crosses over a double yellow line into opposing traffic, unless justified by an emergency not of the driver’s own making, violated the Vehicle and Traffic Law and is guilty of negligence as a matter of law” (… see Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1126[a] …). Here, although the evidence demonstrated that there was snow or slush on the surface of the subject road, the adverse weather conditions, as well as the fact that the road sloped downhill, were foreseeable and known to Barreto and did not provide a nonnegligent explanation for Barreto’s violation of the Vehicle and Traffic Law … . Although the evidence demonstrated that there was a vehicle stopped in the bus’s lane of travel, thereby obstructing its path, the evidence also demonstrated that the stopped vehicle was observable from a far distance, that the bus did not slow down after the stopped vehicle came into Barreto’s view, and that Barreto crossed over the double-yellow line without slowing down. Under the circumstances, Barreto’s loss of control over the bus was the result of his own negligent driving in adverse weather conditions, rather than the result of an emergency not of his own making. The absence of an emergency was recognized by the Supreme Court in its refusal to grant the defendant’s request that the jury be given an instruction on the emergency doctrine.
Barreto’s operation of the bus under the circumstances here violated Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1120(a). Such violation constitutes negligence as a matter of law and could not properly be disregarded by the jury … . Hodnett v Westchester County Dept. of Pub. Works & Transp., 2020 NY Slip Op 01603, Second Dept 3-11-20