You are here: / / IN THIS TERMINATION OF PARENTAL RIGHTS PROCEEDING, PETITIONER DID NOT MEET...
,

IN THIS TERMINATION OF PARENTAL RIGHTS PROCEEDING, PETITIONER DID NOT MEET ITS BURDEN TO PROVE IT MADE DILIGENT EFFORTS TO ASSIST RESPONDENT MOTHER IN ADDRESSING HER MENTAL HEALTH; MOTHER’S PARENTAL RIGHTS SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN TERMINANTED (THIRD DEPT).

The Third Department, reversing Family Court, determined the petitioner did not prove it made diligent efforts toward reunification of mother and child, given mother’s mental health and the incomplete measures to address her mental health needs. Therefore mother’s parental rights should not have been terminated. The facts are far too complex to summarize here:

The petitioning agency “bears the burden of proving . . . that such diligent efforts were made,” and must do so by clear and convincing evidence … . To satisfy that burden, the agency “must develop a plan that is realistic and tailored to fit [the] respondent’s individual situation” … , and “make affirmative, repeated, and meaningful efforts to assist the parent in overcoming these handicaps” … . The petitioning agency “should mold its diligent efforts to fit the individual circumstances so as to allow the parent to provide for the child’s future’ ” … .

… [The] “terms and conditions” placed upon respondent required … that she “undergo a complete mental health evaluation by a licensed professional approved by [petitioner]”; engage in a domestic violence program; attend all of the child’s medical appointments and all scheduled visitation; and “successfully complete Family Services of Chemung County’s Protective Parenting Program.” We agree with respondent and the AFC that petitioner did not prove, by clear and convincing evidence, that it made diligent efforts to assist respondent in satisfying these conditions. Matter of Willow K. (Victoria L.), 2023 NY Slip Op 03730, Third Dept 7-6-23

Practice Point: Here mother had serious mental health issues and the “terms and conditions” imposed upon mother required those issues to be addressed in specific ways. Petitioner did not prove it diligently provided sufficient assistance to mother in her attempts to meet those terms and conditions. Therefore mother’s parental rights should not have been terminated.

 

You might also like
OUT-OF-POSSESSION LANDLORD MAY BE LIABLE FOR PLAINTIFF’S SLIP AND FALL ON ICE WHICH FORMED ON THE STEP LEADING TO HER APARTMENT, DESPITE IT BEING PLAINTIFF’S RESPONSIBILITY TO REMOVE ICE AND SNOW FROM THE AREA (THIRD DEPT).
FOR CAUSE CHALLENGES TO TWO JURORS SHOULD HAVE BEEN GRANTED, CONVICTION REVERSED (THIRD DEPT).
Determination Annulled and Expunged—Hearing Officer Did Not Take Any Steps to Confirm the Reliability of the Confidential Information Upon Which the Determination Was Based
SUPREME COURT ADDRESSED THE MERITS OF THE ACTION WITHOUT DISCOVERY AND TRIAL; THE COURT SHOULD ONLY HAVE DECIDED WHETHER PETITIONER WAS ENTITLED TO A PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION; MATTER REMITTED FOR PROCEEDINGS BEFORE A DIFFERENT JUDGE (THIRD DEPT).
Court Should Not Have Summarily Determined Declaratory Judgment Action In Absence of a Request to Do So/The Mootness Doctrine Precluded Court Rulings on an Expired Contract/The Open Meetings Law Was Violated by the Town
Garagekeeper’s Lien Ineffective Against Owner of Leased Vehicle/Lessee Did Not Have Apparent Authority to Consent to Vehicle Repair and Storage on Owner’s Behalf
TOWN BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW IS A QUASI-JUDICIAL BODY IMMUNE FROM SUIT, 42 USC 1983 CAUSES OF ACTION AGAINST TOWN ASSESSORS INDIVIDUALLY CAN GO FORWARD.
Absence of Complete Financial Disclosure Did Not Preclude Family Court from Making “Change-of-Circumstances” Determination

Categories

Sign Up for the Mailing List to Be Notified When the Site Is Updated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2025 New York Appellate Digest, Inc.
Site by CurlyHost | Privacy Policy

THE JUDGE SHOULD HAVE ALLOWED TIME FOR OBJECTIONS TO PETITIONER’S APPLICATION... THE DEFENDANT’S ACCOMPLICE TO MURDER CONVICTION RESTED ENTIRELY ON THE...