You are here: / / BOTH PARENTS OPPOSED VISITATION WITH THE GRANDPARENTS AND THERE WAS EVIDENCE...
, ,

BOTH PARENTS OPPOSED VISITATION WITH THE GRANDPARENTS AND THERE WAS EVIDENCE VISITATION WITH THE GRANDPARENTS HAD NEGATIVE EFFECTS ON ONE OF THE CHILDREN; IT WAS NOT DEMONSTRATED THAT VISITATION WITH THE GRANDPARENTS WAS IN THE CHILDREN’S BEST INTERESTS; MATTER REMITTED FOR A NEW HEARING BEFORE A DIFFERENT JUDGE (THIRD DEPT). ​

The Third Department, reversing Family Court, determined Family Court’s ruling allowing visitation by the grandparents, which was opposed by both parents, was not demonstrated to be in the best interests of the children. The son is autistic and has frequent “meltdowns” which the grandparents allegedly didn’t handle appropriately. The matter was sent back for a new hearing in front of a different judge:

In granting visitation to the grandparents, Family Court essentially based its determination on its belief that the son would benefit from frequent contact with family members who love him, and that “equity demand[ed]” that the daughter have the same level of visitation. While contact with loving family members is certainly a laudable goal for these and any other children, the record does not support the court’s finding that the children’s best interests would be served by visitation with the grandparents. Indeed, to the contrary, the mother and the father, who were separated as of the time of the hearing but were united in their opposition to the grandparents’ visitation petition, offered testimony detailing the negative effects that visitation with the grandparents had on the son. Matter of Virginia HH. v Elijah II., 2022 NY Slip Op 06970, Third Dept 12-8-22

Practice Point: Here both parents opposed visitation with the grandparents and there was evidence such visitation had negative effects on one of the children, who is autistic. It was not demonstrated visitation with the grandparents was in the children’s best interests. The case was remitted for a new hearing before a different judge.

 

You might also like
PETITION ALLEGED MOTHER FAILED TO GIVE ADHD MEDICATION TO THE CHILDREN; THE NEGLECT PETITION SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN DISMISSED WITHOUT A HEARING; BECAUSE FAMILY COURT ADDRESSED THE MERITS OF THE MOTION TO REARGUE THE MOTION WILL BE DEEMED TO HAVE BEEN GRANTED RENDERING THE ORDER APPEALABLE AS OF RIGHT (THIRD DEPT).
Claimant Did Not Demonstrate a Compelling Reason to Close His Business—Unemployment Insurance Benefits Denied
RETROACTIVE APPLICATION OF THE FORECLOSURE ABUSE PREVENTION ACT (FAPA) WHERE FINAL JUDGMENT HAS NOT BEEN RENDERED DOES NOT VIOLATE PLAINTIFF’S DUE PROCESS RIGHTS; HERE THE DEBT WAS ACCELERATED IN 2008 AND THE CURRENT FORECLOSURE PROCEEDING IS THEREFORE UNTIMELY PURSUANT TO THE FAPA (THIRD DEPT). ​
LAW OFFICE FAILURE DEEMED AN ADEQUATE EXCUSE FOR PLAINTIFF’S COUNSEL’S FAILURE TO APPEAR AT THE MANDATORY CONFERENCE IN THIS FORECLOSURE ACTION; PLAINTIFF BANK’S MOTION TO VACATE THE DEFAULT JUDGMENT SHOULD HAVE BEEN GRANTED (THIRD DEPT).
Venue Was Not Proper—However, Because the Party Seeking the Change of Venue Did Not Comply With the Statutory Procedure, Whether to Grant a Change of Venue Was Discretionary—In the Exercise of Discretion, Change of Venue Was Properly Denied
Attesting Witnesses Did Not See Decedent’s Signature on the Will and One Attesting Witness Did Not Know the Document Was a Will—The Will Was Not Duly Executed and the Petition for Probate Was Properly Dismissed
Defendant Who Pled to All Charges Without a Plea Bargain Could Not Be Required to Waive Appeal
UNDER THE PUBLIC HEALTH LAW CERTAIN DOCUMENTS RELATED TO A HOSPITAL DEATH THAT WERE NOT PART OF A QUALITY ASSURANCE INVESTIGATION SHOULD HAVE BEEN MADE AVAILABLE TO PETITIONER.

Categories

Sign Up for the Mailing List to Be Notified When the Site Is Updated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2025 New York Appellate Digest, Inc.
Site by CurlyHost | Privacy Policy

IN THIS COMPLEX CASE INVOLVING ALLEGED MISUSE OF LAND GIFTED TO THE AUDUBON... PETITIONER POLICE OFFICER’S SLIP AND FALL WHEN LEAVING A BATHROOM MET...