THE WARRANTLESS SEARCH OF THE RESIDENCE WAS NOT JUSTIFIED BY THE EMERGENCY EXCEPTION TO THE WARRANT REQUIREMENT (FOURTH DEPT).
The Fourth Department, reversing defendant’s conviction and dismissing the indictment, determined the warrantless search of defendant’s residence by an evidence technician was not justified under the emergency exception to the warrant requirement. A woman called 911 and reported she had found her roommate unconscious in the residence. When the evidence technician arrived she was told the roommate was dead. The technician then went through the residence taking pictures. She discovered what appeared to be illegal drugs. A search warrant was issued and drugs and a handgun were seized:
The court held that the initial search of the residence by the evidence technician was justified under the emergency exception to the warrant requirement, which permits a warrantless search in the presence of three elements: ” ‘(1) the police must have reasonable grounds to believe that there is an emergency at hand and an immediate need for their assistance for the protection of life or property and this belief must be grounded in empirical facts; (2) the search must not be primarily motivated by an intent to arrest and seize evidence; and (3) there must be some reasonable basis, approximating probable cause, to associate the emergency with the area or place to be searched’ ” … . …
Prior to engaging in her initial search, … the evidence technician had observed the body in the bathroom, and her suppression hearing testimony did not include any observation suggesting that a crime had occurred, much less that an assailant was still in the home or that there was an ongoing risk of harm … . … [N]othing in the 911 call or in the testimony of the officers who initially arrived at the residence suggested that the woman had been the victim of an attack … . … [T]he evidence technician lacked a ” ‘reasonable basis, approximating probable cause’ ” to associate any emergency that might have once existed, i.e., an unresponsive woman lying in the bathroom, to the search of the bedrooms of the residence … . People v Hidalgo-Hernandez, 2021 NY Slip Op 07404, Fourth Dept 12-23-21