You are here: / / DOCUMENTS CREATED AND HELD BY A PRIVATE ENTITY PURSUANT TO THE REGULATIONS...

DOCUMENTS CREATED AND HELD BY A PRIVATE ENTITY PURSUANT TO THE REGULATIONS OF A STATE AGENCY ARE NOT “RECORDS” WHICH THE STATE AGENCY MUST DISCLOSE PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION LAW, DESPITE THE FACT THAT THE AGENCY CAN DEMAND PRODUCTION OF THE DOCUMENTS (THIRD DEPT).

The Third Department, reversing Supreme Court, determined documents created and held by a private entity (Union) pursuant to a state agency’s (New York Department of Labor’s) regulations regarding apprenticeship programs are not “records” which the Department of Labor is required to produce under the Freedom of information Law (FOIL):

… [R]espondent [New York Department of Labor] did not delegate a duty to the Union nor did the Union perform any essential service on respondent’s behalf. The mere fact that respondent has the discretionary regulatory authority to ask the Union for the requested documents does not, ipso facto, render all documents that are created and maintained by the Union with respect to its apprenticeship programs subject to disclosure (see Public Officers Law § 86 [4]). Practically speaking, to so hold would render any document that was created or maintained by a private entity in order to comply with a corresponding agency regulation requiring the production and retention thereof a “record” subject to disclosure under FOIL (see Public Officers Law § 86 [4]) … . …

Although we recognize that “FOIL is to be liberally construed and its exemptions narrowly interpreted so that the public is granted maximum access to the records of government” … , we do not find the definition of “record” to be so broad and all-encompassing as to bring within its ambit any document that a private entity might create and maintain pursuant to a state agency’s regulation under the guise that said records are held “for” that agency (see Public Officers Law §§ 86 [4]; 87 [2]; 89 [3] [a] …). Matter of Broach & Stulberg, LLP v New York State Dept. of Labor, 2021 NY Slip Op 03509, Second Dept 6-3-21

 

You might also like
PLAINTIFF HIGH SCHOOL BASEBALL PLAYER ASSUMED THE RISK OF BEING STRUCK WITH A BALL DURING A PRACTICE DRILL WHERE MULTIPLE BALLS WERE IN PLAY; TWO DISSENTING MEMORANDA (THIRD DEPT).
ATTORNEY HIRED FOR DOCUMENT REVIEW WAS AN EMPLOYEE ENTITLED TO UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE BENEFITS, DESPITE THE ATTORNEY’S SIGNING A DOCUMENT INDICATING SHE WAS AN INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR (THIRD DEPT).
FAMILY COURT’S BEST INTERESTS RULING IN THIS MODIFICATION OF CUSTODY PROCEEDING DID NOT HAVE A SOUND AND SUBSTANTIAL BASIS IN THE RECORD; THE APPELLATE DIVISION AWARDED PRIMARY PHYSICAL CUSTODY TO MOTHER (THIRD DEPT). ​
Even Though Husband’s Funds Were Deposited in a Joint Account, the Portion of those Funds Used for a Down-Payment on the Marital Residence Was Properly Deemed Husband’s Separate Property; Supreme Court Abused Its Discretion In Ordering the Sale of the Marital Residence—Wife Entitled to Exclusive Possession Until Child Turns 18
Insurance Agent Was an Employee, Not an Independent Contractor
GRANDMOTHER DID NOT DEMONSTRATE A PROLONGED SEPARATION OF THE CHILD FROM MOTHER OR THE MOTHER’S RELINQUISHMENT OF CONTROL AND CARE, CUSTODY SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN AWARDED TO GRANDMOTHER.
THERE ARE TWO STATUTORY PROCEDURES FOR APPROVING AN EXTENSION OF A SEWER DISTRICT; HERE THE REQUEST FOR AN EXTENSION WAS INITIATED UNDER ONE STATUTORY PROCEDURE, WHICH DOES NOT REQUIRE A REFERENDUM, BUT THE TOWN APPLIED THE OTHER STATUTORY PROCEDURE, WHICH DOES REQUIRE A REFERENDUM; THAT WAS ERROR (THIRD DEPT).
COUNTY COURT DID NOT HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO ALLOW PEOPLE TO AMEND A DEFECTIVE CONSPIRACY COUNT BY ADDING AN ALLEGED OVERT ACT.

Categories

Sign Up for the Mailing List to Be Notified When the Site Is Updated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2026 New York Appellate Digest, Inc.
Site by CurlyHost | Privacy Policy

KINGS COUNTY SUPREME COURT HAD JURISDICTION TO ISSUE EAVESDROPPING WARRANTS... PLAINTIFF ALLEGED THE INCREASED TRAFFIC RELATED TO AN EVENT AT DEFENDANT COUNTRY...