You are here: / / The Prosecutor’s Acting As an Unsworn Witness (Suggesting He Had...
,

The Prosecutor’s Acting As an Unsworn Witness (Suggesting He Had Been Present at a Trial In Which the Defense Expert Had Lied) and The Prosecutor’s Repeated Questioning of the Expert and Another Defense Witness About Their Alleged Lying Deprived Defendant of a Fair Trial on the Murder Count

The Second Department reversed defendant’s murder conviction because of the misconduct of the prosecutor in questioning the defense expert and another defense witness.  The prosecutor acted as an unsworn witness by suggesting he was present in a trial where the defense expert lied and the prosecutor improperly and repeatedly questioned the expert and another defense witness about their alleged lying:

The prosecutorial misconduct during the voir dire questioning and cross-examination of the defense’s expert included statements that the expert had repeatedly lied to judges in other cases and during his testimony in the instant case. In addition, the prosecutor presented himself as an unsworn witness at the trial, suggesting that he had been present at the trial of another case at which the defendant’s expert had lied. The prosecutor furthermore repeatedly questioned another defense witness about lying. The cumulative effect of this misconduct … unfairly deprived the defendant of the ability to present his defense of extreme emotional disturbance to the charge of murder in the second degree … . People v Martinez, 2015 NY Slip Op 03568, 2nd Dept 4-29-15

 

You might also like
Defendant Homeowner Demonstrated She Did Not Have Actual or Constructive Notice of the Dangerous Condition and Did Not Create the Dangerous Condition (Deck Collapsed When Plaintiff Was Inspecting the Property Prior to Beginning Work)
THE CLIMATOLOGICAL RECORDS WERE NOT CERTIFIED AS BUSINESS RECORDS AND THEREFORE COULD NOT BE RELIED UPON TO SHOW A STORM IN PROGRESS AT THE TIME OF THE SLIP AND FALL; PROOF OF A GENERAL INSPECTION ROUTINE COULD NOT BE RELIED UPON TO SHOW THE ABSENCE OF CONSTRUCTIVE NOTICE OF THE BLACK ICE (SECOND DEPT).
Burden of Proof for Relocation with Child Not Met
FAILURE TO RESPOND TO DISCOVERY DEMANDS AND OBEY COURT ORDERS WARRANTED STRIKING DEFENDANTS’ ANSWERS IN THIS MEDICAL MALPRACTICE ACTION.
Foreign Corporation’s Sole Residence for Venue Purposes Is the County Designated In Its Filed Application to Conduct Business in New York State
THE DOCUMENTS RELIED UPON FOR THE REFEREE’S REPORT WERE LISTED BUT NOT SUBMITTED, RENDERING THE REPORT INADMISSIBLE HEARSAY (SECOND DEPT).
Defense of Lack of Personal Jurisdiction Is Not Waived by Making a Motion to Dismiss on that Ground/Process Server’s Testimony About Attempts to Locate Defendant Lacked Credibility
Complaint Can Not Be Deemed Dismissed in Absence of Final Judgment

Categories

Sign Up for the Mailing List to Be Notified When the Site Is Updated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2026 New York Appellate Digest, Inc.
Site by CurlyHost | Privacy Policy

The Decision Whether to Raise the Defense of Justification Is for the Defendant,... Attempted Criminal Possession of a Weapon Third Degree Is Not a Violent Felony...